Medications & Psychiatry

 email page    print page

All Topic Reviews
Psychiatry Under the InfluenceAlternatives Beyond PsychiatryAmerican MadnessAmerican PsychosisAn Unquiet MindAntipsychiatryBad PharmaBefore ProzacBetter Than ProzacBiological PsychiatryBipolar, Not So MuchBlack Man in a White CoatBlaming the BrainBrain Science and Psychological DisordersBrainwashedClinical Psychopharmacology Made Ridiculously SimpleComfortably NumbCompassion and Healing in Medicine and SocietyComplete Mental HealthConcise Guide to PsychopharmacologyCrackedCritical PsychiatryCultural FormulationDeconstructing PsychosisDemystifying PsychiatryDiagnosing the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental DisordersDiagnosis: SchizophreniaDiagnostic Issues in Depression and Generalized Anxiety DisorderDimensional Models of Personality DisordersDisordered Personalities and CrimeDoctoring the MindDoctors of DeceptionDrop the Disorder!DruggedDrugs for LifeEmpirical Ethics in PsychiatryEssential PsychopharmacologyEssential Psychopharmacology of Depression and Bipolar DisorderEssentials of Psychiatric DiagnosisEsssential Philosophy of PsychiatryEthics in PsychiatryEvidence-Based Treatment of Personality DysfunctionExercise-Based Interventions for Mental IllnessFinding the Right Psychiatrist:Forces of HabitHandbook of Clinical Psychopharmacology for TherapistsHappy Pills in AmericaHealing the Soul in the Age of the BrainHelping Parents, Youth, and Teachers Understand Medications for Behavioral and Emotional ProblemsHerbs for the MindHigh PriceHippocrates CriedHistory of Psychiatry and Medical PsychologyHookedHuman TrialsInfectious MadnessInspired SleepIntoxicating MindsIs It Me or My Meds?Let Them Eat ProzacLife-Threatening Effects of Antipsychotic DrugsLitLiving with Bipolar DisorderMad in AmericaMad ScienceMalignant SadnessMedicating ChildrenMedicating Modern AmericaMental Health in Asia and the PacificMind FixersMoments of EngagementMommy I'm Still in HereNatural Healing for DepressionNo One Cares About Crazy PeopleNot CrazyOrdinarily WellOur Daily MedsOverdosed AmericaPathologist of the MindPediatric PsychopharmacologyPediatric PsychopharmacologyPediatric PsychopharmacologyPharmaceutical FreedomPharmacracyPharmageddonPharmageddonPhilosophical Issues in PharmaceuticsPoets on ProzacPower HerbsPowerful MedicinesPrescriptions for the MindProfits Before People?Prozac and the New AntidepressantsProzac As a Way of LifeProzac BacklashProzac DiaryProzac on the CouchPsychiatric DiagnosisPsychiatric HegemonyPsychiatrists and Traditional HealersPsychiatry and EmpirePsychiatry and the Business of MadnessPsychiatry as Cognitive NeurosciencePsychiatry at a GlancePsychiatry in PrisonsPsychiatry ReconsideredPsychopathyPsychopharmacology Problem SolvingPsychotropic Drug Prescriber's Survival GuidePsychotropic Drugs And Popular CulturePsychotropic Drugs: Fast FactsRaising Generation RxRe-Visioning PsychiatryRecovery from SchizophreniaReligious and Spiritual Issues in Psychiatric DiagnosisRitalin NationRunning on RitalinRutter's Child and Adolescent PsychiatrySaving NormalSchizophreniaShock TherapyShock TherapyShould I Medicate My Child?ShrinksSide EffectsSometimes Amazing Things HappenStraight Talk about Psychiatric Medications for KidsSuccessful PsychopharmacologySuffer the ChildrenTaking America Off DrugsTalking Back to ProzacTextbook of Cultural PsychiatryThe $800 Million PillThe Age of AnxietyThe Anti-Depressant Fact BookThe Antidepressant EraThe Antidepressant SolutionThe Antidepressant Survival ProgramThe Big FixThe Book of WoeThe Complete Guide to Herbal MedicinesThe Conceptual Evolution of DSM-5The CorrectionsThe Creation of PsychopharmacologyThe Cult of PharmacologyThe Dream DrugstoreThe Emperor's New DrugsThe Essential Guide to Prescription Drugs 2005The Essential Guide to Prescription Drugs 2006The Making of DSM-III®The Medical Model in Mental HealthThe Medicated ChildThe Medication QuestionThe Merck DruggernautThe Mind/Mood Pill BookThe Natural Pharmacist : Natural Health Bible from the Most Trusted Alternative Health Site in the World The Pill BookThe Pill Book Guide to Natural MedicinesThe PlaceboThe Rise and Fall of the Biopsychosocial ModelThe Sedated SocietyThe Therapist's Guide to PsychopharmacologyThe Therapist's Guide to Psychopharmacology, Revised EditionThe Truth About the Drug CompaniesThe Use and Misuse of Psychiatric DrugsThe World of CaffeineThomas S. SzaszToxic PsychiatryTrouble in MindTry to RememberTry to RememberTwilight of American SanityUnderstanding Physician-Pharmaceutical Industry InteractionsUnhingedVoluntary MadnessWarning: Psychiatry Can Be Hazardous to Your Mental HealthWhat Is Mental Illness?What Psychiatry Left Out of the DSM-5What Works for Whom?Will@epicqwest.comWomen, Madness and MedicineYour Drug May Be Your Problem

Related Topics
Mad ScienceReview - Mad Science
Psychiatric Coercion, Diagnosis, and Drugs
by Stuart A. Kirk, Tomi Gomory, David Cohen
Transaction Publishers, 2013
Review by Duncan Double
Jan 21st 2014 (Volume 18, Issue 4)

What justification can there be for yet another book attacking psychiatry? After all, as the authors of this book say, "many critical books about psychiatry and the disease model have been published, especially recently" (p. 300). Their answer is that this is the first book to examine the links between three major areas: the role of coercion; the emptiness of descriptive diagnosis since the third revision of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM); and the madness of psychiatric drugs. Actually, consideration of these matters is kept rather separate in different chapters of the book and I don't think there is really any new material that has been introduced. It's not until the last chapter that alternatives are discussed. But if we give due accord to their claim, then maybe this book is the clearest to argue for the abandonment of coercive psychiatry since the death of Thomas Szasz.

What is more obviously probably unique about this book is that it has been written by three social workers. They first began meeting in 2004 in New York City. All have an independent history of academic critical publications challenging the disease model of distress and behavior. They clearly understand the social dimension of mental health interventions. Yet they conclude that the thoughts, feelings and behaviors of those identified as mentally ill are "normal human experiences in all their varieties" (p. 322). They think that professionals should only offer voluntary treatment and that physicians' prescription privileges should be abolished. The motivation for this position is the gross misinterpretation by mainstream psychiatry of the empirical evidence.

They appreciate that their conclusion about non-coercion is historically inconsistent with the modern origins of psychiatry in the detention of people in lunatic asylums. In England, voluntary admission was only possible after the Mental Treatment Act 1930. Even then, application needed to be made in writing to the person in charge of the hospital. The Mental Health Act 1959 set the foundations for modern psychiatric treatment and made informal admission the usual method of admission.

The locked doors of the psychiatric hospitals started to be opened in the 1950s. The peak of the mental health population in the UK and USA was the mid-1950s and later in other Western countries. The traditional asylums became increasingly irrelevant to the bulk of mental health problems and began their decline as alternative services were developed. True, most of these community services are provided on a voluntary basis but the incidence of detention in hospital has become more common, not less, as the length of admission to hospital has reduced. And, despite even my concerns, supervised community treatment was introduced in England following the amendment of the Mental Health Act in 2008, paralleling similar developments such as outpatient commitment in the USA. So, although the focus of psychiatry has broadened from inpatient detention, the role of coercion has endured against the wishes of the authors of this book.

I agree with the authors about the unscientific nature of the claim that mental disorders have been established to be brain diseases. I am also aware of psychiatry's history of abusive treatment and of course want to minimise the use of coercion. I'm not a social worker, but my social understanding leads me, contrary to the authors, to recognise the degree to which psychiatry is inevitably a social intervention. However much they may wish to abandon psychiatry's social role, even with the expansion of community psychiatry beyond the asylum, I think their aim is wrong and unrealistic. Of course the autonomy of mentally disordered people should be encouraged and realistic hope given to them in their recovery, but psychiatric illness can be mentally incapacitating. If this wasn't the nature of mental illness, psychiatry, in my view, would not have a raison d'être. Of course psychotherapy has developed as an individual practice in the same way that the authors would presumably like their "social" treatment to develop. But, I think that psychiatry is inevitably more than individual practice and I would have liked to have seen more discussion of this issue in the book.

Most of the book is taken up with the critique of mainstream psychiatry. That's relatively easy and any attempt to create a solution in the last chapter is relatively thin by comparison. I thought there were particularly useful aspects in all three main areas of the critique that they discussed. For coercion, their assessment of the value of assertive outreach was pertinent. For diagnosis, their insights into the politics of the development of DSM were valuable. For medication, their emphasis on three large scale evidenced based studies (CATIE, STAR*D and STEP-BD) sponsored by the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) that had poor therapeutic results is important. I thought it was also helpful that they pointed out the extent to which historians of psychiatry may have tended to hanker after a biological view of mental illness, even though their historical narrative highlighted the importance of context. This perspective may have always tended to be the case, as, for example, even the most interpersonal of psychiatrists, such as Harry Stack Sullivan, still believed that severely damaged schizophrenic presentations have an organic cause.

My different perspective from the authors of this book could be said to reflect the division in so-called anti-psychiatry between RD Laing and Thomas Szasz. I have always tended to be attracted to the Laingian view, whereas the authors of this book follow Szasz's line. It's probably about time that the number of critiques of psychiatry came to an end. The focus may need to shift to providing a way forward. There may be more disagreement about this than the more consensual nature of the critique, with which mainstream psychiatry has essentially failed to engage anyway.


© 2014 Duncan Double


Duncan Double is a Consultant Psychiatrist and Honorary Senior Lecturer, Norfolk & Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust and University of East Anglia, UK; blogs at critical psychiatry.


Welcome to Metapsychology.

Note that Metapsychology will be moving to a new server in January 2020. We will not put up new reviews during the transition. We thank you for your support and look forward to coming back with a revised format.

We feature over 8300 in-depth reviews of a wide range of books and DVDs written by our reviewers from many backgrounds and perspectives. We update our front page weekly and add more than twenty new reviews each month. Our editor is Christian Perring, PhD. To contact him, use one of the forms available here.

Metapsychology Online reviewers normally receive gratis review copies of the items they review.
Metapsychology Online receives a commission from for purchases through this site, which helps us send review copies to reviewers. Please support us by making your purchases through our Amazon links. We thank you for your support!

Join our Google Group!

Interested in becoming a book reviewer for Metapsychology? To apply, write to our editor.

Metapsychology Online Reviews

Promote your Page too

Metapsychology Online Reviews
ISSN 1931-5716