email page print pageAll Topic Reviews
50 Reasons People Give for Believing in a God50 Voices of DisbeliefA Companion to Buddhist PhilosophyA Companion to Muslim EthicsA Frightening LoveA Mirror Is for ReflectionA Mirror Is for ReflectionA People's History of ChristianityAdieu to GodAn Ethics for TodayAristotle's ChildrenAugustine's "Confessions"Bad FaithBehind the GospelsBeyond the SelfBig DreamsBig GodsBody Piercing Saved My LifeBrains, Buddhas, and BelievingBrief Inquiry into the Meaning of Sin and FaithBuddhism and ScienceBuddhist Boot CampConfucianismConfucianismConfucius and ConfucianismContemplative ScienceCorporal Punishment, Religion, and United States Public SchoolsCourage to SurrenderCross and KhoraDarwin's Gift to Science and ReligionDarwin, God and the Meaning of LifeDeath and the AfterlifeDebating DesignDeeper Than DarwinDivinity of DoubtEmbracing MindEncountering the DharmaEngaging BuddhismEsalenEscape Your Own PrisonEvidence for PsiEvilEvolution and ReligionExplorations in Neuroscience, Psychology and ReligionFaithFaith and Wisdom in ScienceFingerprints of GodFor The Bible Tells Me SoForgivenessFrom Shame to SinGodGod & TherapyGod Is Not GreatGod Is Not OneGod: The Failed HypothesisHereticHidden DimensionsHooked!Hours with the MysticsHow to See Yourself As You Really AreHow Would Buddha Act?Incorporating Spirituality in Counseling and PsychotherapyInto Great SilenceIslam and the Future of Tolerance: A DialogueJewish DharmaLife After FaithLiving DeeplyLiving with a Wild GodLiving with DarwinMaking Chastity SexyMedicine and Health Care in Early ChristianityMedicine and ReligionMedicine of the PersonMorals Not KnowledgeMysticism & SpaceNature and the Human SoulNothingOn Life After DeathPanpsychism and the Religious AttitudePathways to SpiritualityPeaceful Death, Joyful RebirthPhilosophers without GodsPhilosophical Myths of the FallPorn UniversityPray the Gay AwayPsychotherapy without the SelfPurgatoryRadical GraceReason, Faith, and RevolutionRecruiting Young LoveReligion without GodReligious and Spiritual Issues in Psychiatric DiagnosisSaving GodScience and NonbeliefScience and Religion at the CrossroadsScience and SpiritualityScience vs. ReligionSecular Philosophy and the Religious TemperamentSelf Hypnosis for Cosmic ConsciousnessSelf, No Self?Sex and the Soul, Updated EditionSmile of the BuddhaSong of RiddlesSpirit, Mind, and BrainSuperstitionTen Lectures on Psychotherapy and SpiritualityThe Accidental MindThe Belief InstinctThe Bodhisattva's BrainThe Cambridge Companion to AtheismThe Cambridge Companion to Science and ReligionThe Case for GodThe Chosen OneThe Dao of NeuroscienceThe Dark Night of the SoulThe Darkening AgeThe Delight of Being OrdinaryThe Forgotten CreedThe Fundamentalist MindsetThe God DebatesThe God GeneThe Hero with a Thousand FacesThe Improbability of GodThe Joy of SecularismThe Language God TalksThe Language of GodThe Meaning of BeliefThe MiracleThe New AtheismThe New Religious IntoleranceThe Philosophy of ReligionThe Power of FaithThe Power of ForgivenessThe Power of Religion in the Public SphereThe Psychology of Religious FundamentalismThe Psychology of SpiritualityThe Puppet and the DwarfThe Secular OutlookThe Sense of SelfThe Spirit of the BuddhaThe Spirit of Tibetan BuddhismThe Tibetan Book of the DeadThe Trauma of Everyday LifeThe Watkins Dictionary of Religions and Secular FaithsThe Watkins Dictionary of SymbolsTheology, Psychology and the Plural SelfThoughts Without A ThinkerTop SecretUnifying HinduismWays of KnowingWhat Is Buddhist Enlightenment?What Should I Believe?When the Impossible HappensWhy I Left, Why I StayedWilliam James on Ethics and FaithWriting as a Sacred PathYoga, Karma, and RebirthZealot
Michael Ruse is one of today's leading authorities on the philosophy of biology in general and the history and philosophy of evolutionary theory in particular. He has written or edited about forty-five books on these topics, making him an obvious choice to author the Evolution and Religion volume for Rowman & Littleman's New Dialogues in Philosophy series.
The dialogue is framed in terms of five episodes of a fictional public-television talk-show called Eternal Questions. Besides Redvers Fentiman, who serves as moderator, there are four participants in the discussion panel, each of whom more or less represents a different position in the quartet of modes for relating science and religion that was first invented by Ian G. Barbour: Prof. David Davies is an atheist evolutionary biologist whose disdain for religion is reminiscent of the real world Richard Dawkins. He represents the "conflict" model, which holds science and religion to be incompatible. Martin Rudge is an historian and philosopher of science who represents the "independence" model, which holds that science and religion need not conflict because they are not really dealing with the same questions. Reverend Emily Matthews, a rather liberal-minded Episcopalian priest represents the "integration" model; she adopts ideas from outside the mainstreams of both evolutionary theory and Christian theology in an attempt to fashion a unified scientific-religious world view. Finally, Reverend Harold Wallace is the head pastor of a Southern Baptist megachurch and has received some training in physics before he turned to religion. He represents the "dialogue" position, which holds that religion and science have something to say to each other. As a "young earth" creationist, he seems to feel that religion should do most of the talking.
Ruse has the characters slug it out with each other as they discuss practically every major issue in the evolution-religion debate, including intelligent design, "young earth" creationism, the origins of life, non-Darwinian elements in contemporary evolutionary theory, the puzzle of the "Cambrian explosion" of life, the meaning of divine intervention, and the political uses and implications of evolutionary theory. He also treats one issue not properly belonging to biological evolution: the "strong anthropic" or "fine-tuning" argument, which tries to prove the existence of a Creator from the nature of certain basic parameters of physics. Ruse tries to let each of his characters both score and lose points in the argument, but Reverend Matthews seems to lack intellectual rigor, and it is pretty clear that (despite his best efforts) Ruse cannot really take Reverend Wallace's extreme creationism seriously.
How does this book shape up as a primer on the Religion-Evolution debate? It is clearly written and it does cover a lot of ground from various viewpoints. It is, however, a rather short book -- only 136 pages including endnotes -- and occasionally Ruse introduces ideas without granting them enough space to be properly explained. In the middle of the discussion of the "fine-tuning" argument, for instance, the unprepared reader is suddenly confronted with the claim that, "To make carbon from helium, you need a huge energy state above normal -- in fact, about 7 million electron volts (MeV) above normal" (p. 73). Similarly, more discussion would be needed to give the reader a reasonable idea of what Process Theology is all about.
The dialogue format may make the book fun to read, but it also leaves it without the kind of clear-cut logical structure that would make it easier to find references to particular topics and concepts. That lack of structure is especially unfortunate given the publisher's incomprehensible decision not to equip the book with an index, a move which seriously detracts from its usefulness as a text for undergraduate courses. It is also disappointing that the book contains no illustrations, charts, or diagrams. Perhaps the author or publisher thought that such graphic devices would have disrupted the impression that the book simply records unrehearsed conversations, but they also would have greatly improved its effectiveness in vividly communicating scientific and philosophical ideas. Nevertheless, this book does provide an amusing way to become acquainted with the basic positions in the evolution-religion controversy, and its endnotes offer many useful bibliographical suggestions for further exploration.
© 2009 Berel Dov Lerner
Berel Dov Lerner teaches philosophy at the Western Galilee College in Israel.
Welcome to Metapsychology.
We feature over 8200 in-depth reviews of a wide range of books and DVDs written by our reviewers from many backgrounds and
We update our front page weekly and add more than twenty new reviews each month. Our editor is Christian Perring, PhD. To contact him, use one of the forms available here.
Metapsychology Online reviewers normally receive gratis review copies of the items they review.
Metapsychology Online receives a commission from Amazon.com for purchases through this site, which helps us send
review copies to reviewers. Please support us by making your Amazon.com purchases through our Amazon links. We thank
you for your support!
Join our e-mail list!: Metapsychology New Review Announcements: Sent out monthly, these
announcements list our recent reviews. To subscribe, click
Interested in becoming a book reviewer for Metapsychology? Currently, we especially need thoughtful reviewers
for books in fiction, self-help and popular psychology. To apply, write to our editor.
Metapsychology Online Reviews
Promote your Page too
Metapsychology Online Reviews