email page print pageAll Topic Reviews
1000 Families2 ¼32 Stories365 Days51 Months5x7A Child's Life and Other StoriesA Couple of Ways of Doing SomethingA Lifetime of SecretsA Storybook LifeA Treasury of Victorian MurderActing OutAddiction and ArtAEIOUAfter PhotographyAliveAlive with Alzheimer'sAlone Together POCAltered StatesAmazing WomenAmelia's WorldAmerica at HomeAmerican AlphabetsAmnesiaAn American LensAn Exact MindAngel's WorldAngry Youth Comix #2Anjos ProibidosAnthony GoicoleaArchitecture of AuthorityArt After Conceptual ArtArt and HomosexualityArt and PhotographyArt in Three DimensionsArt Photography NowArt, Self and KnowledgeArt/PornAs We AreAsylumAttitudeAutoportraitBecoming Edvard MunchBeg the QuestionBelugaBerkoBig Rabbit's Bad MoodBill HensonBlab!Blab! 13BLAB! Vol. 14BLAB! Vol. 15BlanketsBoneyardBoneyardBoy StoriesBreakdownsBright EarthBrüselBurn, Bitchy, BurnBus OdysseyBut Is It Art?CanvasCaricatureChildrenChris VereneChristy ReportCinema PanopticumClass PicturesClick DoubleclickCloserClumsyClyde Fans CoincidencesComing of AgeComing of Age in Ancient GreeceConceptual Art and PaintingConfessions of a Cereal EaterConsider LoveCouch FictionCrumpleCzech EdenCzech Photographic Avant-Garde, 1918-1948Dan & LarryDargerDays With My FatherDead EndDear MomDeus Ex MachinaDigital DiariesDirty StoriesDisasters of WarDixie RoadDomestic VacationsDon't Go Where I Can't FollowDon't You Feel BetterDr. Jekyll & Mr. HydeDrawingsDriftlessEarly ExposuresEcstasyEdouard VuillardEnduring CreationEngland, My EnglandEntering GermanyEpilepticErwin OlafEscape from "Special"EVAEverything Will DisappearEvidenceExploring the Self through PhotographyExposureExpressionism Exquisite CorpseFamilyFamilyFamily LifeFandomaniaFaster than a Speeding BulletFictionsFigure and GroundFragile DVDFred the ClownFreud at WorkFridaFrom Girls to GrrlzFun HomeGeneration DadaGirl CultureGirls, Some Boys and Other CookiesGoing Into TownGood-ByeGraphic WomenGrave MattersGreat Hiking Trails of the WorldH R GigerHans BellmerHappy Halloween, Li'L SantaHauntedHere Is New YorkHey, Wait...High Art LiteHollywood CowboyHouse of JavaI Am Not This BodyI Love You But I've Chosen RockI Thought I Could FlyI'll Be Your MirrorI'm CrazyIllumineIn My Darkest HourIn Search Of DignityIn the Floyd ArchivesIn the Line of DutyInformation ArtsIntenseInvisible No MoreIt Was A Dark And Silly NightJack Cole and Plastic ManJimmy CorriganJock SturgesJock SturgesJust Between UsKafkaKatharina SieverdingLacan at the SceneLaura Numeroff's 10-Step Guide to Living with Your MonsterLife's a BitchLight in the Dark RoomLine of Beauty and GraceListening to CementLittle LitLi’l SantaLoadsLooking For MayaLost GirlLouis FaurerLouise BourgeoisLove and DesireLove Lust DesireLuckyManufactured LandscapesMass ObservationMaster BreastsMetacreationMisty DawnMnemosyneMomeMona KuhnMy Brain is Hanging Upside DownMy DepressionMy Family AlbumNatural BeautiesNatural BeautyNerveNerveNew and Used BLAB!New York September 11Night FisherNightswimmingNo More ShavesNot My ShameNotes from a DefeatistNothing ObviousNothing to HideNudes and PortraitsOliviaOlivia Saves the CircusOn City StreetsOne EyeOnly a Promise of HappinessOptic NerveOptic Nerve #11Optic Nerve #9Outlaws, Rebels, Freethinkers & PiratesOutsider ArtOutsider Art and Art TherapyPanic at Toad HallPatrolPaul M. SmithPeculiaPeekPeople Love PhotosPerfect ExamplePersepolisPhilosophersPhonesexPhoto ArtPhoto Icons I (1827-1926)Photographers, Writers, and the American ScenePhotography and LiteraturePhotography and PhilosophyPhotography and SciencePhotography and the USA Photography RebornPicturing DisabilityPlaytimePOPismPortraits of ResiliencePostmodernismPsychedelicQuestions without answersRaptors Raw YouthRay's a LaughRazmatazReclining NudeRed SnowRemembering GeorgyRequisite DistanceRineke DijkstraRippleRobert Doisneau 1912-1994Robert MaxwellRoom to PlayRXSame Difference & Other StoriesSanctumSatan's Sex BookSatellitesSchizophreniaSee Me Feel MeSelf-Taught and Outsider ArtSexSexual ArtSexyBookShadow ChamberSidewalk StoriesSkin DeepSleepwalkSmall FavorsSmile of the BuddhaSpectral EvidenceSpentSshhhh!Stranded in CantonStrange Stories for Strange Kids Stranger PassingStripped BareSummer BlondeSurrealismSymbols in ArtTestimonyThe Aesthetics of DisengagementThe AlcoholicThe Art InstinctThe Art of Adolf WolfliThe Art of MedicineThe BabiesThe Birthday RiotsThe Blue Day BookThe Blue NotebookThe BodyThe Body as ProtestThe Boulevard of Broken DreamsThe Breast BookThe Breathing FieldThe Bristol Board JungleThe Clouds AboveThe Devil and Daniel JohnstonThe Diary of a Teenage GirlThe Education of SophieThe Erotic Lives of WomenThe Face in the LensThe Illustrated Story of OThe Incantations of Daniel JohnstonThe Madonna of the FutureThe Mirror of LoveThe New Erotic PhotographyThe New LifeThe Other PlaceThe PervertThe Philosophy of Andy WarholThe Places We LiveThe Psychology of Art and the Evolution of the Conscious BrainThe Push Man and Other StoriesThe Scar of VisibilityThe September 11 Photo ProjectThe Shiniest JewelThe Speed AbaterThe Steerage and Alfred StieglitzThe Story of Frog Belly Rat BoneThe Story of SexThe Stuff of LifeThe Three ParadoxesThe Transformations of GwenThe Transformations of GwenThe Transparent CityThe TravelersThe ValleyThe Van Gogh BluesThe Wolves in the WallsThe Yellow HouseThinThings as They AreThinking of YouTierney GearonTime and SilenceTina's MouthTits, Ass, and Real EstateTransitionTrauma and Documentary Photography of the FSATravelersTropical BlendTwentieth Century EightballTwilightUnlikelyVagina WarriorsVernacular VisionariesVietnam At PeaceVisual CultureVitamin PhWar Is Only Half the StoryWhat Are You Looking At?What Art IsWhat Good Are the Arts?What Remains: The Life and Work of Sally MannWho Am I, What Am I, Where Am I?Why Comics?William KentridgeWillie DohertyWithWriters on ArtistsYoung PhotographerZip Zip My Brain Harts
Cynthia Freeland's But
Is It Art? provides an introduction to issues and problems surrounding the
interpretation and understanding of contemporary art. On the one hand her style is easily accessible and should provide
a solid introduction to the art novice.
On the other hand the subject matter is provocative. Her examples of the varied, and often
controversial sorts of objects and events any contemporary theory of art must
be able to account for are lucid and engaging.
The content of this book challenges the reader to recognize the
complexity of contemporary art and as a result the difficulty of providing it a
Freeland identifies a
problem for our understanding of art.
In the contemporary context art can take many forms. She describes a seminar at a past annual
meeting of the American Society for Aesthetics. The topic of the session was "Blood and Beauty." The content of the session was the role of
bodily fluids in contemporary art. In
the ritual practice of ancient and "primitive" societies blood and
other bodily fluids often play a symbolic spiritual role, representing life,
fertility, or the relation of individuals to earth itself as their
embodiment. Artists who employ this
medium reference these ritualistic practices as a natural and direct form of
Freeland identifies a
difficulty for this type of art. Its
medium gains ritualistic content only by virtue of a shared community that is
unified in "agreement of purpose."
Within such a context bodily fluids can be employed as a medium that
reinforces the individuals' relation to their community and its
spirituality. But, whereas one might
interpret art viewing as a modern social ritual, contemporary art viewers in
museums, galleries, and performance spaces share no such community relative to
the ritualistic use of bodily fluids.
As a result the ritualistic theory of art that grounds the use of this
medium cannot account for its role in contemporary art.
The difficulty is
compounded by the fact that these works cannot easily be fit into traditional
aesthetic theories. These theories
define art either as the apprehension of beauty or relative to their
representational or expressive qualities.
In fact, these works are so jarring and disturbing that they seem the
antithesis of what is traditionally conceived of as art. Consider Andres Serrano's Piss Christ
(1987). The work is a richly saturated
color photograph of a crucifix floating in a jar of urine. We do not share the appropriate agreement of
purpose to interpret this work.
Further, as one can imagine, the majority of the American public summarily
denounced it as insulting, offensive, and defamatory. In short it was not, in the popular opinion beyond the artworld,
suitable subject matter for art.
Freeland suggests a
cognitive theory of art that she believes explains how (or if you prefer, why)
this sort of work is categorized as art.
The theory is derived in part from Lucy Lippard's (Art in America,
April 1990) art-critical model for explaining Piss Christ. Lippard analyzes the work from three
angles: its form and material; its
content; and its context. The work is a
large color print, 60 x 40 inches. It
is a Cibachrome print. This means it is
glossy with deeply saturated colors, and its surface is very delicate, easily
ruined by a fingerprint or a slight speck of dust. The image is not recognizable as a crucifix floating in the
artist's own urine. The jar cannot be
read from the print. Rather, a crucifix
is presented in a golden, rosy medium within which constellations of tiny
bubbles have been frozen in space. For
all we know the crucifix could be suspended in amber or polyurethane. The formal qualities of the work are, in
fact, quite mysterious and beautiful.
The material qualities
of the work are only apparent with addition of the title that alters the
context of the work from its formal to its material existence. But even here the interpretation is
ambiguous. Freeland indicates that
Serrano was raised in a Latino-American Catholic community for whom bodily
suffering and bodily fluids are seen as sources of religious power and strength
(she is not explicit here but I assume she is referring to the crucifixion of
Christ and the transmutation of wine in communion). Furthermore, within this community it is common for bones and
other remains to be stored in vials in churches and cherished as sacred
relics. The material quality of the
work would not, as a result, in and of itself be offensive.
Serrano contends that
the work was not intended to denounce religion, but rather to point to the
manner in which contemporary culture is commercializing and cheapening
Christian icons. This content can only
be read off of the work by understanding the context in which to interpret the viewer's
contact with the material and formal qualities of the work.
Freeland takes the
definition of art from the anthropologist Richard Anderson. Art is "culturally significant meaning,
skillfully encoded in an affecting sensuous medium." In other words art is, as John Dewey
claimed, "the expression of life in the community." This definition centers on Freeland's
definition of an "interpretation."
An interpretation is an explanation of how a work functions to
communicate thoughts, emotions, and ideas.
On this model explanation is defined pragmatically. There is no privileged interpretation. Explanations provide knowledge. Knowledge is defined as "what is
instrumental to the enrichment of immediate experience through the control over
action that it exercises."
Therefore art has a cognitive role in our lives. It enriches experience, and in so doing
conveys knowledge of how to perceive the world around us. As a result, interpretation can transform an
experience. It can transform our
self-reflective understanding of who we are and how the world we are embedded
in should be interpreted by transforming our socio-cultural and perceptual
consist of an explanation of the entwined relations among the form/material,
content, and context of a work.
Freeland's intention is that this cognitive theory will enable us to
understand difficult art in a pluralistic artworld. Globalization and diaspora have blurred cultural boundaries. Gender and class consciousness have
shattered traditional aesthetic categories.
The problem of contemporary art is not only the introduction of novel
and sometimes shocking material and content.
There is no longer a static context from which to approach art. The background theory, which Danto has argued
is provided by the artworld for the interpretation of the work, may be
initially opaque to the viewer.
Freeland implies that direct contact with the work along with immersion
in its context is the only way to bridge this boundary and understand contemporary
art. But, as she concedes this may
never be enough. This is why there are
no privileged interpretations. Rather,
through interpretation we gain an understanding of our own perceptual and
Herein lies my only
concern with the interpretation of contemporary art implicit in But Is It
Art? Whereas globalization and
diaspora have blurred cultural boundaries and blended socio-cultural contexts,
her cognitive theory can only resolve the problem she identifies for
contemporary art if works of art are, in general, transparent to the model of
interpretation she suggests. If not, it
may explain how difficult art like Piss Christ could be conceived as
art, but it cannot explain why they are art, i.e. it will not provide us the
appropriate context with which to interpret the work.
© 2002 Bill Seeley
Bill Seeley is a doctoral candidate in
the Program in Philosophy at CUNY - The Graduate Center working on the
neurophysiology of aesthetic perception. He also has an M.F.A. in sculpture
from Columbia University. His work has been exhibited in New York City, at Yale
University, and at The Addison Gallery of American Art in Massachussets. He
teaches ethics and aesthetics at Hofstra University.