In the introduction to The Virtue of Defiance and Psychiatric Engagement, Nancy Nyquist Potter warns her readers that the book may satisfy neither philosophers nor psychiatrists. As an interdisciplinary effort, her project is ambitious – it is to update Aristotelian virtue theory in light of the complexities and injustices of contemporary life, especially with respect to persons with mental health problems; and then to persuade psychiatrists not only that patient defiance should be evaluated for virtuosity, but that psychiatrists need to cultivate in ourselves a newly proposed virt Click here to read the full review!
Liza Tsaliki's Children and the Politics of Sexuality provides a much needed counter-voice to the widely held beliefs current in the Western World that children are 'naturally' sexually innocent, and that they should remain that way at least until later adolescence or early adulthood. I see three major influences on Tsaliki's book, and I will shape my review around those (related) sources: the French historian, Phillippe Aries, the French philosopher, Michel Foucault, and third wave feminism.
Aries' book, Centuries of Childhood (1962) was the first serious historical analysis of childhood, an Click here to read the full review!
On Betrayal By Avishai Margalit Review by Wendy C. Hamblet, Ph.D. on Tue, Apr 25th 2017.
Values and vices shift radically over time in all societies and cultures. However, betrayal is one of those enduring vices the weight of whose forms may wax and wane with political and historical circumstances, but whose definition can be agreed upon by most human beings across the globe, a definition generally grounded in the primal experience of being betrayed, that is, cast from the perspective of the victim. Betrayal is a fundamental human experience that arouses a deep emotional response because in its "thickest" form, it destroys the "thick" relations that bind family and friends, underm Click here to read the full review!
Racing the Devil By Charles Todd Review by Christian Perring on Tue, Apr 25th 2017.
Inspector Ian Rutledge from Scotland Yard is called out to a small town in the South of England, the Sussex coast, when a cleric is killed in a car accident and it looks like foul play. He investigates but before he knows what happened, other people start dying. It is soon after the Great War, and Rutledge is haunted by many terrible memories of his time in the army. One of the men who died back there, Hamish, is a constant companion in his head, giving him advice and engaging him in dialog. Racing the Devil is a rather standard historical detective mystery with a striking theme Click here to read the full review!
In The meaning of evil, James Sias takes the reader on a journey that overviews the meaning and use of the word evil. This journey, however, is not an easy or simple one. The polythetic dimensions that comprise the meaning and use of the word evil force his scholarly investigation not only to be multilayered and detail-oriented, but also to incorporate, in a rich tapestry of facts, conventions of daily use and theoretical speculations.
The diverse contexts where the word evil is exercised, which represent its complex and imprecise meanings, require the author to distinguish carefully between Click here to read the full review!
Against Empathy The Case for Rational Compassion By Paul Bloom Review by Christian Perring on Tue, Apr 18th 2017.
Paul Bloom makes a strong case against the use of empathy as a way to conduct our moral lives, although as several reviewers such as Constantine Sandis, have already pointed out, there is some ambiguity about what he means by it, and arguably he has defined it so narrowly that his thesis is less interesting than it sounds. He focuses on emotional empathy, where one feels the emotions that other people feel. He also includes cognitive empathy, which is directly relating to their cognitive states such as beliefs and desires, although it's not clear exactly what that means. To cognitively empathi Click here to read the full review!
Freud An Intellectual Biography By Joel Whitebook Review by Michael Maidan on Tue, Apr 18th 2017.
Joel Whitebook is a practicing psychoanalyst, a teacher and researcher associated with Columbia University where he directs the Psychoanalytic Studies Program. His Freud: An Intellectual Biography 'is a study of the relation between the unfolding of his thinking and crucial developments in his life history' (16). The book is a readable, enjoyable and well-documented biography of Freud that summarizes current scholarship, and makes good use of recently published archival materials. But, it is also more than that. Whitebook argues that we can identify two aspects in Freud's theory. O Click here to read the full review!
Sophie Spikey Has a Very Big Problem A story about refusing help and needing to be in control By Sarah Naish, Rosie Jefferies and Amy Farrell Review by Christian Perring on Tue, Apr 18th 2017.
This UK book for young children tells the story of Sophie who is very young and is living with her new parents. We don't learn what happened to her old parents, but we do find out that Sophie had to learn to do a lot on her own when she was extremely young. Now, she doesn't like to be helped and is suspicious of people who try to help her. One day she and her Mum are going to go out shopping, but Sophie can't find her new shoes. So she gets out her old shoes from the trash can and gets a wet foot walking around. When her Mum notices, she works out what has gone wrong and talks her through the Click here to read the full review!
Trans Gender and Race in an Age of Unsettled Identities By Rogers Brubaker Review by Guilel Treiber on Tue, Apr 11th 2017.
During the summer of 2015 two events in the US colluded in creating what Rogers Brubaker calls a 'trans moment'. A moment in which people not only thought of trans as an identity but thought with trans as a category. A category that epitomizes the fluidity and multiplicity (or lack thereof) of identity and the possibility to move from one to another identity or to remain in an in-betweeness of identities. Even for those living outside the US the two events are quite well known. The first event was the coming out of Caitlyn Jenner (previously Bruce Jenner) as a M2F trans woman; the second event Click here to read the full review!
In this book with a vague title[] Christine Tappolet aspires to provide us with "a highly attractive account of emotions" (xi). This is a brave attempt given the less than 200 pages of the text. As a result the argument is dense, yet still some issues are left aside. The book is a reworking of Tappolet's earlier contributions: of the five chapters only one is entirely new. I am not convinced if the project is completely successful: the five chapters are of varying quality and do not always match one another. Each chapter is closed with a tiny (no more than 1 page long) conclusion and, regre Click here to read the full review!
Means, Ends, and Persons The Meaning and Psychological Dimensions of Kant's Humanity Formula By Robert Audi Review by Ebrahim Azadegan on Tue, Apr 11th 2017.
Robert Audi's aim in this book is to introduce an ethics of conducts to show that how our actions, intentions and manner of treating others ought to be interrelated in order to constitute a good conduct. He starts with Kantian humanity formula of his categorical imperative that we must treat persons as ends in themselves and never merely as a means. But he goes far beyond Kant's in constituting his ethics of conducts. He argues that neither utilitarianism nor Kantianism nor even virtue ethics could provide broadly enough frameworks for realization of multidimensional conception of moral respon Click here to read the full review!
In 400 pages, CUNY sociologist William Helmreich describes the neighborhoods of Brooklyn and makes recommendations about what to see when walking. The book is split into 43 different sections, one per geographical region, so each gets about 5-10 pages, including a map and some black and white photos. So The Brooklyn Nobody Knows is an easy book to dip into. Helmreich writes in the first person, describing his walks moving from street to street, reporting on the people he sees, who he encounters, and what it is like to be there. He gives recommendations about how to safe in the rare cases of da Click here to read the full review!
Garson's book revolves around one single question: what is a biological function? The author presents us an overview of most answers provided to the question, which is a task that is complex and at times confusing but for sure, useful. Garson's systematic, articulate and down-to-earth writing style should be praised, being effective in providing intelligibility to what is known to be an intricate topic. The author's critical perspective and his own answer to the book's main question are presented in last chapter.
But let us first frame the ques Click here to read the full review!
Memory and the Self Phenomenology, Science and Autobiography By Mark Rowlands Review by Majid Davoody Beni on Tue, Apr 4th 2017.
For those of us who, like one of the author's boys, are curious about "[w]here do our memories go when we lose them?" it would be a joy to read Memory and the Self (2016). The book is a multidisciplinary enquiry concerning the relation between the memory and the self. Memory, despite its inaccuracies and deficiencies, has an indispensable role in the constitution of the (autobiographical) self. Almost all the other elements of the book are mentioned in the title. That is to say, Rowlands relied on the resources of the phenomenological tradition (works of Brentano, Husserl, Heidegger, Pro Click here to read the full review!
Steven J. Taylor has focused on filling in the gaps and adding to the historical understanding and research of mental illness in children during a specific time period during the nineteenth century into the twentieth century. In Child Insanity in England, 1845-1907, Taylor focuses his attention on five pauper (meaning poor or not wealthy) lunatic asylums in both rural and urban areas. According to Taylor, the asylums were used primarily to control the deviant and insane population even though certain legal enactments existed to attempt to treat those deemed insane.
Taylor uses a cultural Click here to read the full review!
Welcome to MHN's unique book review site Metapsychology.
We feature over 7700 in-depth reviews of a wide range of books and DVDs written by our reviewers from many backgrounds and
We update our front page weekly and add more than thirty new reviews each month. Our editor is Christian Perring, PhD. To contact him, use one of the forms available here.
Can't remember our URL? Access our reviews directly via 'metapsychology.net'
Metapsychology Online reviewers normally receive gratis review copies of the items they review. Metapsychology Online receives a commission from Amazon.com for purchases through this site, which helps us send
review copies to reviewers. Please support us by making your Amazon.com purchases through our Amazon links. We thank
you for your support!
Join our e-mail list!:Metapsychology New Review Announcements: Sent out monthly, these
announcements list our recent reviews. To subscribe, click
Interested in becoming a book reviewer for Metapsychology? Currently, we especially need thoughtful reviewers
for books in fiction, self-help and popular psychology. To apply, write to our editor.