email page print pageAll Topic Reviews
"Intimate" Violence against Women3 NBS of Julian DrewA Little PregnantA Natural History of RapeA Parent's Guide to Asperger Syndrome and High-Functioning AutismA Stir of BonesAbout a BoyAdult Children of Emotionally Immature ParentsAgainst MarriageAgainst MarriageAlmost a PsychopathAlone TogetherAnatomy of LoveAngelsAnother CountryAnxious ParentsApples and OrangesBe Honest--You're Not That Into Him EitherBeing the Other OneBetrayed as BoysBeyond AddictionBipolar DisorderBoys Will Put You on a Pedestal (So They Can Look Up Your Skirt)Breaking ApartBrief Adolescent Therapy Homework PlannerBringing Up ParentsBut I Love HimCaring for a Child with AutismCaring in Remembered WaysCherishmentChildren of the Aging Self-AbsorbedChildren of the Self-AbsorbedChildren, Families, and Health Care Decision MakingClawsCloserCold HitCoping With Difficult PeopleCouple SkillsCruddyDancing in My NuddypantsDivorce PoisonDoing ItDone With The CryingEcstasyEmotional ClaustrophobiaEmotional Fitness for IntimacyEmotional Intelligence at WorkEntwined LivesErotic PassionsEssentials of Premarital CounselingEvery Pot Has a CoverFacts About ADHD ChildrenFamilies Like MineFamilyFamily BoundFamily FirstFear of IntimacyFinal JeopardyFind MeFlashpointFor Lesbian ParentsForgive Your Parents, Heal YourselfGandhi's WayGeorgia Under WaterGetting over Getting MadGetting the Love You WantGetting the Love You Want Audio CompanionGirl in the MirrorGirl StuffGoing Home without Going CrazyHandbook of AttachmentHandbook of Counseling and Psychotherapy with Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual ClientsHappiness Sold SeparatelyHard to GetHe's Just Not That Into YouHealing ConversationsHollow KidsHot ButtonsHot Chocolate for the Mystical LoverHow Families Still MatterHow to Create Chemistry with AnyoneHow to Give Her Absolute PleasureHow to Handle a Hard-To-Handle KidHow to Keep Your Teenager Out of Trouble and What to Do If You Can'tI am Not Sick I Don't Need Help!I Don't Know How She Does ItI Hate You-Don't Leave MeI Only Say This Because I Love YouI'm OK, You're My ParentsIn the Mood, AgainInside the American CoupleIntrusive ParentingIt's Called a Breakup Because It's BrokenIt's Love We Don't UnderstandJakarta MissingKeeping Passion AliveKeeping Your Child in MindLet's Get This StraightLiberation's ChildrenLife's WorkLikely to DieLove JunkieLove SickLove Times ThreeLove Works Like ThisLoving Someone With Bipolar DisorderLoving Someone with Borderline Personality DisorderLust in TranslationMaking the RunMaking the RunManic DepressionMars and Venus - Starting Over.Mating in CaptivityMom, Dad, I'm Gay.MotherstylesMurder in the InnMysterious CreaturesNecessary NoiseOdd Girl OutOpenOpening to Love 365 Days a YearOphelia's MomOrgasmsOur Journey Through High Functioning Autism and Asperger SyndromeOut of the DustOvercoming Your Difficult FamilyParenting and the Child's WorldParenting on the GoParenting Your Out-Of-Control TeenagerParents and Digital TechnologyParents Do Make a DifferencePassionate MarriagePlanet JanetPreventing Misbehavior in ChildrenProblem Child or Quirky Kid?Raising AmericaRaising ElijahRaising Kids in an Age of TerrorRaising Kids in the 21st CenturyRaising Resilient ChildrenRay's a LaughRelationship RescueRelax, It's Just SexRespect-Me RulesRomantic IntelligenceRoom For JSecrets of a Passionate MarriageSelf-NurtureSelfish, Shallow, and Self-AbsorbedSex Addiction: The Partner's PerspectiveShidduch CrisisSickenedSingleSlut!Socrates in LoveSomeone Like YouSong for EloiseSpecial SiblingsSpiritually Healing the Indigo Children (and Adult Indigos, Too!)Staying Connected to Your TeenagerStaying Sane When Your Family Comes to VisitStop Arguing with Your KidsStop SignsStop Walking on EggshellsStop Walking on EggshellsStrong, Smart, & BoldSummer of the SkunksSurviving a Borderline ParentTaking Charge of AngerTelling SecretsThank You for Being Such a PainThe Anti-Romantic ChildThe AwakeningThe Bastard on the Couch CDThe Birth of PleasureThe Brief Couples Therapy Homework Planner with DiskThe Bully Action GuideThe Burden of SympathyThe Commercialization of Intimate LifeThe CorrectionsThe Couples Psychotherapy Treatment PlannerThe DisappearanceThe Dream BearerThe Educated ParentThe Emotional RevolutionThe Employee Assistance Treatment PlannerThe EpidemicThe Ethics of ParenthoodThe Ethics of the FamilyThe Gay Baby BoomThe Good DivorceThe Guide for International Intercultural Couples and Families Intercultural MarriageThe Healing Journey for CouplesThe Hostile HospitalThe Husbands and Wives ClubThe Inside Story on Teen GirlsThe Introvert AdvantageThe Little FriendThe Love HexagonThe Moral Intelligence of ChildrenThe Neuroscience of Human RelationshipsThe New I DoThe Normal OneThe Nurture AssumptionThe OASIS Guide to Asperger SyndromeThe Other ParentThe Philosophical ParentThe Psychology of Parental ControlThe Real Rules for GirlsThe Reflective ParentThe Right to Be ParentsThe Secret Lives of WivesThe Spider and the BeeThe State of AffairsThe StepsThe Story of My FatherThe Velveteen FatherThe Virgin BlueThe Visitation HandbookThe Whole ChildTo Have and To Hurt:Two Is EnoughUnderstanding MarriageUnderstanding the Borderline MotherUnhitchedUp in FlamesWe've Got IssuesWhat about the KidsWhat Goes UpWhat Is Secular Humanism?What It Means to Love YouWhat Our Children Teach UsWhen a Parent is DepressedWhen Mars Women DateWhen Someone You Love Is BipolarWhen Someone You Love Is DepressedWhy Are You So Sad?Will You, Won't You?WomanWorking With Emotional IntelligenceWorried All the TimeYes, Your Teen Is Crazy!
The value and dis-value of the family, and how and whether the family should be regulated, are vivid questions among contemporary philosophers -- as they have usually been among scholars from other disciplines and members of the non-academic public. But what is a family in the first place? Judith Stacey's book makes it plain that contemporary families come in a variety of forms and hence that it is an illusion that one could find an adequate morphological definition of the family. Anthropology and sociology have, of course, always been useful in pointing out that the heterosexual, nuclear and monogamous family that is usually the norm in Western societies is only one type of family organization. But this book has the merit of closely exploring two types of families that are not salient even in the enlarged imaginary of the family: First, families created by individuals belonging to sexual minorities who decide to pursue their own models of shared life and parenting with others. Stacey focuses on gay, rather than lesbian, families. Relationships within these families are structured by individual's desires and moral commitments rather than by social expectations. Second, the readers are familiarized to the contemporary matriarchal family of the Mosou minority living in West China. In this review I focus on chapters concerning these two sorts of families, although the book also contains two chapters on polygamy; the latter are particularly interesting because they explain how the revival of polygamy in South Africa interacts with the history of racism and ideologies of cultural difference.
The first two chapters look at families -- that is, marriage-like partnerships involving two or more partners as well as parenting -- in the United States. Stacey tells stories of several gay men whose evolution she has followed over a decade; these are stories of people who prize both the open acknowledgment of their sexual desires and -- many of them -- the pursuit of romantic, often long-term and committed, partnerships, with or without the aim of also raising children. The stories illustrate well the author's contention that, given their place on the fringe of the society, gays are more able to accept their erotic identities in spite of cultural pressure to conform with norms of monogamy. Similarly, these chapters offer an introduction to the gay cruising culture in which issues of status, wealth or education are a lot less important than they are in other social contexts. Such environments can breed more egalitarian romantic and erotic, sometimes long-term, relationships than one is likely to encounter elsewhere: they make possible partnerships between individuals from very different social, economic and cultural backgrounds. Moreover, child-rearing gay families -- that often involve several gay and lesbian individuals and/or couples -- sometimes pursue explicit agendas of egalitarian relationships between partner. The appendix illustrates this point, allowing readers to see a co-parenting agreement.
The Mosuo people -- who make the object of the last chapter before the conclusions -- is a minority living in southwestern China. Their traditional, two millennia old family organization is peculiar in that children of both sexes never leave their mothers' homes and usually do not share a household with their romantic or erotic partners, even in cases when they engage in life-long monogamous relationships. Indeed, the Mosuo language lacks a word for 'marriage'. Instead, Mosuo separate entirely their family life -- where common economic activities and childrearing happens -- from their romantic life, where they are free to pursue none, one or multiple relationships; anthropologists describe the Mosuo as a uniquely non-judgmental culture with respect to sexual matters. Thus, children are being raised by their biological mothers, grandmothers, aunts and uncles and do not necessarily know their biological fathers. This arrangement is said to render stability to family life because it saves individuals the significant stress of sharing adult life with individuals from different families, with different habits; at the same time it is praised for protecting romantic relationships from the threat of every-day routine and the burdens of family obligations. In addition, the Mosuo families empower women encourage egalitarian choices of romantic partners and avoids double standards in sexual morality. If all this is true, the Mosuo does offer a very ingenuous model of organizing social life. Unfortunately, Mosuo traditional families risk disintegration: some of their children study far away from home and eventually marry and join regular family arrangements. And a very successful touristic industry -- fueled by the uncommon family Mosuo organization and their probably undeserved reputation of sexual licentiousness -- threatens the cultural conformity that is necessary for reproducing the Mosuo family.
Somewhat unexpectedly, the conclusions bring child-rearing issues to the forefront. (Only the second chapter of the book, on gay parenthood, had engaged directly with child-rearing, and even in that section of the book the focus is on parents', rather than children's, lives.) According to Stacey, her book should better equip us to see that, since marriage is not a universal institution, it cannot be the foundation of a successful society, and so fatherhood cannot be necessary to promoting the interests of children. This is of course true, if fatherhood is defined by reference to the nuclear monogamous family which Stacey's work so compellingly shows to be just one model of the family. But I suppose that at least some readers will want to say that, in fact, children growing up the Mosou societies enjoy plenty of fathering from their uncles and maternal grandfathers. The same applies to children reared by multi-parent gay families.
The book is openly taking a strong normative stance against attempts at regulating the family by prohibiting certain sorts of marriage or marriage-like associations, such as gay or polygamous marriage, or matrilineal child-rearing families. In some situations the author has a strong case: when family arrangements, no matter how unorthodox, are not likely to involve either coercion or harm to non-consenting parties. In other cases, however, the book seems to miss the fact that not all regulation is equally undesirable. Thus, the author compares the Maoist attempts at dismantling Mosuo matrilineal and matrilocal families to 'the attempts by the U.S. Federal government to “liberate” Mormon women and children from polygamy'. (p.169) Throughout reading it, I thought the book would be better without such comparative evaluations of attempts at regulating the family; I remain unconvinced that we should be equally wholehearted in championing individuals' freedom to enroll themselves -- and others -- in all forms of private associations.
© 2012 Anca Gheaus
Anca Gheaus is a post-doctoral researcher at the Philosophy Faculty of the Erasmus University in Rotterdam. She works on theories of care and justice on which she has published several book chapters and articles in Raisons Politiques, Feminist Theory, Basic Income Studies and Hypatia.