Depression
Resources

 email page    print page

All Topic Reviews
A Mood ApartA Sadly Troubled HistoryActive Treatment of DepressionAdolescent DepressionAdult Bipolar DisordersAgainst DepressionAgents in My BrainAmerican ManiaAmerican MelancholyAn Unquiet MindArtificial HappinessBeating the BluesBefore ProzacBeyond BlueBiological UnhappinessBipolar DisorderBipolar Disorder DemystifiedBipolar Disorder in Childhood and Early AdolescenceBipolar DisordersBipolar ExpeditionsBlaming the BrainBoy InterruptedBritain on the CouchCalm EnergyCase Studies in DepressionChange Your ThinkingChronic DepressionComprehending SuicideConquering Postpartum DepressionConquering the Beast WithinCry Depression, Celebrate RecoveryDamageDepressionDepression 101Depression and GlobalizationDepression and NarrativeDepression Doesn't Always Have to Be DepressingDepression FalloutDepression in ContextDepression Is a ChoiceDepression SourcebookDepression, Emotion and the SelfDepression, the Mood DiseaseDepression-Free for LifeDetourDiagnostic Issues in Depression and Generalized Anxiety DisorderDown Came the RainDowning Street BluesDysthymia and the Spectrum of Chronic DepressionsEight Stories UpElectroboyElectroshockEssential Psychopharmacology of Depression and Bipolar DisorderExperiences of DepressionFacing BipolarFast GirlFatal AttachmentsGetting Your Life BackGod HeadHandbook of DepressionHandbook of DepressionHello to All ThatHelping Students Overcome Depression and AnxietyHow Everyone Became DepressedHow I Stayed Alive When My Brain Was Trying to Kill MeHurry Down SunshineI am Not Sick I Don't Need Help!Journeys with the Black DogLeaving YouLet Them Eat ProzacLife InterruptedLifeForce Yoga to Beat the Blues--Level 1LifeForce Yoga to Beat the Blues: Level 2Lifting DepressionLifting the WeightLincoln's MelancholyLiving Without Depression and Manic DepressionLong ShotLucy Sullivan Is Getting MarriedMadnessMaking Sense of SuicideMalignant SadnessManiaManicManic DepressionManufacturing DepressionMelancholiaMindfulness for Urban Depression: Tools for Relief from Stressful City LivingMindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy for DepressionMood GenesMoody Minds DistemperedMy DepressionNatural Healing for DepressionNew Hope for Children and Teens with Bipolar DisorderNew Hope For People With Bipolar DisorderNew Hope for People with DepressionNight Falls FastNovember of the SoulOn DepressionOn the Edge of DarknessOne in ThirteenOrdinarily WellOut of the BlueOutsmarting DepressionOvercoming DepressionPerfect ChaosPotatoes Not ProzacProzac and the New AntidepressantsProzac BacklashProzac HighwayProzac NationProzac NationPsychotic DepressionPuppy Chow Is Better Than ProzacQuiet Your Mind & Get to SleepRaising a Moody ChildReasons to Stay AliveScattershotSelf-CoachingSightlinesSilencing the Self Across CulturesSilent GriefSongs from the Black ChairSongs Without WordsSpeaking of SadnessSpontaneous HappinessStudent DepressionSubordination and DefeatSuicidal Behavior in Children and AdolescentsSuicideSunbathing in the RainSurvival Strategies for Parenting Children with Bipolar DisorderSurviving Manic DepressionSwing LowSylvia Plath ReadsTalking Back to ProzacTaming Your Inner BratThe Aesthetics of DisengagementThe American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook of Mood DisordersThe Anatomy of MelancholyThe Anti-Depressant Fact BookThe Antidepressant EraThe Antidepressant SolutionThe Antidepressant Survival ProgramThe BeastThe Bell JarThe Best AwfulThe Bipolar ChildThe Bipolar Disorder Survival GuideThe Blue Day BookThe Breakthrough Depression SolutionThe Clinical Science of Suicide PreventionThe CorrectionsThe Cruelty of DepressionThe Depressed ChildThe Depression CureThe Depression WorkbookThe Devil WithinThe Emotional RevolutionThe Family SilverThe Feeling Good HandbookThe Forgotten MournersThe Loss of SadnessThe Memory of LightThe Mindful Way through DepressionThe Mood CureThe Myth of Depression as DiseaseThe Naked Bird WatcherThe Nature of MelancholyThe Noonday DemonThe Pits and the PendulumThe Postpartum EffectThe Secret Strength of DepressionThe Van Gogh BluesThe Van Gogh BluesThe Weariness of the SelfThe Years of Silence are PastThirteen Reasons WhyThis Close to HappyTo Walk on EggshellsTreatment for Chronic DepressionUndercurrentsUnderstanding DepressionUnderstanding DepressionUndoing DepressionUnhappy TeenagersUnholy GhostUnstuckViniyoga Therapy for DepressionWhat Goes UpWhat the Birds SeeWhat Works for Bipolar KidsWhen a Parent is DepressedWhen Nothing Matters AnymoreWhen Someone You Love Is DepressedWhen Words Are Not EnoughWhen Your Body Gets the BluesWhere the Roots Reach for WaterWhy Are You So Sad?Why People Die by SuicideWill's ChoiceWriting Through the DarknessYou Are Not AloneZelda

Related Topics
Manufacturing DepressionReview - Manufacturing Depression
The Secret History of a Modern Disease
by Gary Greenberg
Simon & Schuster, 2010
Review by Benjamin J. Lovett, Ph.D.
Aug 10th 2010 (Volume 14, Issue 32)

Perhaps the most common piece of information heard about depression today is that it is a disease. "Depression is a disease" is practically a mantra, used to encourage those feeling depressed to consult health professionals. In Manufacturing Depression, Gary Greenberg explores what it would mean for depression to be a disease and how we have come to view it as one. It's a nice idea for a book, but Greenberg's execution of that idea is uneven.

The book is really three separate stories: a history of ideas about the nature, causes, and treatment of depression; a recounting of Greenberg's personal experiences with depression; and a critique of the disease model of depression. The primary story, the historical one, is surprisingly haphazard. Famous thinkers who I expected to see extensive discussion of (e.g., Robert Burton, Melanie Klein, Martin Seligman) are covered either very briefly or not at all. Meanwhile, Greenberg squanders valuable space on tangential information, such as the development of statistical significance tests in agriculture, or Albert Hoffman's discovery of LSD. The problem isn't so much that Greenberg mentions these tidbits, but that he discusses them in such detail that the flow of the core story is lost. In chapter 3, for instance, Greenberg describes the derivation of dyes from sea snails, the development of chemistry in 19th century England, and the origins of the germ theory of disease, although any connections to the depression story are vague and indirect. Occasionally, his departures from the expected historical narrative are interesting (such as his consideration of the Book of Job as a story of depression and its attempted treatment), but they are more often frustrating. His coverage of typical topics (e.g., Kraepelin, Freud, the DSM) is accurate, but marred by his speculative connections between theorists' biographical details and their ideas.

The personal story, which bookends most of the chapters, involves Greenberg's multiple bouts of clinical depression, his participation in a research study aiming to treat depression, and his experiences as a psychotherapist treating clients with depression. Greenberg's descriptions of his own symptoms, his response to treatments (and its monitoring by researchers), and his approach to patients are all interesting. I often found myself wishing for more details and a more systematic presentation of these experiences. Unfortunately, this aspect of the book was short on details and long on meditative reflection that rarely led anywhere.

Finally, we come to Greenberg's critique. If Manufacturing Depression has a thesis, it is that biological/scientific approaches to understanding depression have been manufactured on the basis of thin evidence and unwarranted assumptions. Although Greenberg does not explicitly argue for this claim (his writing style is far too unsystematic for that, and his occasional arguments are actually based on rather tendentious interpretations of the relevant literatures), the book as a whole provides some evidence for the claim. Greenberg's personal experiences with depression (both as a client as a therapist) are meant to illustrate the complexity of depressive symptoms and their origins, and the intractability of finding a simple explanation for depression. His historical sketches are meant to show the wishful thinking and erroneous reasoning of those researchers and theorists who would be so bold as to think that they have explained depression once and for all. While the case is underargued, it contains a valuable lesson nonetheless: despite thousands of scientific studies on depression, we still do not have any explanations which apply to every case, let alone an explanation that leads to a treatment with anything close to guaranteed efficacy.

Unfortunately, that lesson is all that has been established after over 300 pages of Manufacturing Depression. All of Greenberg's other thoughts about depression are just intuitions without any kind of evidence or logical defense; as he admits, "All I really have is belief."  He goes on to speculate that "maybe I don't want to believe that depression is a disease because I am a coward, afraid of a not-so-distant future when doctors know more about me than I possibly can, including how to make me better" (336-7). Ultimately, Greenberg's selective history and recollection of his personal experiences are designed to help him maintain a belief that he admits is merely that – a belief. Readers who already share this belief (that depression is not a disease) may find the book similarly helpful, but those expecting a neutral, representative history of ideas about depression, or a careful, systematic analysis of any of those ideas, will be disappointed.

 

© 2010 Benjamin J. Lovett

 

Benjamin J. Lovett, Ph.D., is an assistant professor of psychology at Elmira College, where his research focuses on psychoeducational assessment and psychiatric diagnosis, and he teaches a variety of courses in applied psychology.


Share

Welcome to MHN's unique book review site Metapsychology. We feature over 7800 in-depth reviews of a wide range of books and DVDs written by our reviewers from many backgrounds and perspectives. We update our front page weekly and add more than thirty new reviews each month. Our editor is Christian Perring, PhD. To contact him, use one of the forms available here.

Can't remember our URL? Access our reviews directly via 'metapsychology.net'


Metapsychology Online reviewers normally receive gratis review copies of the items they review.
Metapsychology Online receives a commission from Amazon.com for purchases through this site, which helps us send review copies to reviewers. Please support us by making your Amazon.com purchases through our Amazon links. We thank you for your support!


Join our e-mail list!: Metapsychology New Review Announcements: Sent out monthly, these announcements list our recent reviews. To subscribe, click here.

Interested in becoming a book reviewer for Metapsychology? Currently, we especially need thoughtful reviewers for books in fiction, self-help and popular psychology. To apply, write to our editor.

Metapsychology Online Reviews

Promote your Page too

Metapsychology Online Reviews
ISSN 1931-5716