Personality Disorders
Resources

 email page    print page

All Topic Reviews
A Bright Red ScreamAntisocial Behavior in Children and AdolescentsAs Your Desire MeBorderline Personality DisorderBorderline Personality DisorderBorderline Personality Disorder and the Conversational ModelChildren of the Self-AbsorbedCoping with BPDCoping with Infuriating, Mean, Critical PeopleDangerous and Severe Personality DisorderDealing with a NarcissistDissociative ChildrenDistancingEnough About YouEvidence-Based Treatment of Personality DysfunctionFatal FlawsFirst Person PluralGet Me Out of HereGirl in Need of a TourniquetGirl, InterruptedHandbook of Personality DisordersHandbook of PsychopathyHidden SelvesHigh RiskI Hate You-Don't Leave MeLet Me Make It GoodLiving with Our GenesLost in the MirrorLoving Someone with Borderline Personality DisorderLyingMapping the Edges and the In-betweenPassionate DeliberationPersonality Disorder: Temperament or Trauma?Personality Disorders in Modern LifePractical Management of Personality DisorderPractical Management of Personality DisorderProzac NationPsychopathyPsychotherapy for Personality DisordersSilencing the VoicesSkin GameStop Caretaking the Borderline or NarcissistStop Walking on EggshellsStop Walking on EggshellsSurviving a Borderline ParentThe Angry HeartThe Buddha & The BorderlineThe Clinical and Forensic Assessment of PsychopathyThe PsychopathThe Psychopath TestThe Siren's DanceThe Sociopath Next DoorThe Survivor PersonalityThrough the Looking GlassUnderstanding and Treating Borderline Personality DisorderUnderstanding the Borderline MotherWhy Is It Always About You?Without ConscienceWomen and Borderline Personality DisorderWomen Living with Self-InjuryWomen Who Hurt Themselves

Related Topics
Mapping the Edges and the In-betweenReview - Mapping the Edges and the In-between
A critical analysis of Borderline Personality Disorder
by Nancy Nyquist Potter
Oxford University Press, 2009
Review by Tony O'Brien RN, MPhil
May 25th 2010 (Volume 14, Issue 21)

With Mapping the Edges and the In-between Nancy Potter has produced an incisive and thoughtful analysis of one of the ethically and clinically troubling problems of psychiatry: borderline personality disorder (BPD). Mapping the Edges is a slim volume of just 176 pages, but it is stimulating reading from beginning to end. Potter challenges readers to think beyond the standard diagnostic model, but she does much more than this. Many critiques of psychiatry stop at the level of broad conceptual analysis and do not engage with clinical problems. Potter is under no illusion that problems such as emotional dysregulation, anger, self harm and disrupted relationships are socially constructed, but she follows Hacking in insisting that there is something there, beyond what is socially constructed. It is this something that clinicians must engage with, but not by means of an objectified, unreflexive conceptual framework. Potter insists that our understanding of BPD is informed by careful analysis of taken for granted concepts, and most importantly, by "epistemic humility": the willingness to let patients tell us what is going on. The second aspect of Potter's analysis is ethical. She draws on Aristotle's ethics of virtue to argue that technique is not enough, clinicians must display the necessary ethical comportment to fully engage with patients, and to fully respect their experience and world view.

Mapping the Edges and the In-between is presented in two parts. Each of the first six chapters examines a defining characteristic of BPD. Potter does not limit herself to the criteria of the DSM, but draws on research into clinicians' experience of working with people with the BPD diagnosis to consider what makes BPD in the mind of clinicians. Hence manipulation, while it is not a DSM criterion, is given extensive treatment, as it frequently mentioned in the professional literature and considered to be a hallmark of BPD. The second section of the book explores application of the Potter's framework of virtue ethics to clinical practice. Potter brings to her analysis a unique combination of philosophical and clinical skills drawn from her background as an academic philosopher and a clinical psychologist.

There is too much in this book to cover all Potter's arguments, but I will briefly discuss "giving uptake" as it is a central concept within Potter's thesis. The term comes from philosopher of language John Austin, and Potter has explored it in previous work on BPD. To give uptake is to recognize the patient's meaning-making, not just in general, but in the particular circumstances of each presentation. If we are to give uptake we cannot treat people as members of a class, we must treat them as individuals. In relation to BPD, if we are to give uptake we will treat each expression of anger, and each self injury, each statement or behavior on its own terms and not assume that it "means" something. For example, Potter warns against treating all expressions of anger as stemming from some childhood cause. It might be that there is a more immediate perceived wrong, and if we gloss over that perceived wrong we are not giving uptake. The result is that just as we feel unheard when someone dismisses our concerns by saying we'll "get over it" people feel unheard if a listener does not give uptake. This idea recurs throughout the book as a reminder that despite the culturally conditioned frameworks traditionally used for understanding BPD, as clinicians we need to reach beyond these traditional frameworks and understand what it is about each individual that gives rise to self injury, anger and impulsivity. "Giving uptake" is not simply relying on the norms of communication; nor does it reduce to respect or empathy. Giving uptake is a virtue, and one that clinicians need to cultivate if they are to achieve another of Potter's central aims, that of assisting the patient to flourish.

Also important to Potter's thesis is the idea of BPD as socially situated. Over 75% of people diagnosed with BPD are women, and this is neither coincidental nor peripheral to treatment. However BPD cannot be wished away by political analysis, important as such analysis is to understanding BPD. The manifestations of BPD are real, and sometimes put the person with the diagnosis at real risk, not to mention causing real distress. Identity serves to illustrate the socially situated nature of BPD. Identity is central to the DSM definition of BPD, but proves to be a slippery concept when subject to conceptual analysis. Not only is identity culturally variable, even within a 'Western' philosophical framework the self/other distinction implied by identity is problematic. Ricoeur's "self as another" demonstrates this, and leads to a political understanding of identity, one placed at risk in a consumer society. Clinicians need to understand the social and political nature of concepts like identity while still responding ("giving uptake") to each individual's unique experience.

Mapping the Edges and the in-between is at heart an ethical analysis, one which insists that clinicians cultivate virtues of critical reflectiveness and humility with regard to what patients are saying when they give voice to distress. This is especially important with BPD given its history as a perjorative label, and given clinicians' tendency to see the behaviors of BPD as both willful and pathological. This view of BPD is paradoxical, as we generally excuse behaviors that are genuinely pathological, and blame people for behavior that is the subject of their will. To work our way through this apparent dilemma requires applied ethical reasoning, not merely skilled psychological intervention. Psychiatry is not free from values nor should it be. But the values that are endorsed must be carefully and reasonably chosen, not recycled from unexamined stereotypes of objectionable behavior. Mapping the Edges and the In-between is a fine example of careful philosophical analysis which is valuable not only for those seeking to understand BPD, but for any clinician who seeks a critically informed practice.

 

© 2010 Tony O'Brien

 

Tony O'Brien RN, MPhil, Senior Lecturer, Mental Health Nursing, University of Auckland, a.obrien@auckland.ac.nz


Share

Welcome to MHN's unique book review site Metapsychology. We feature over 7900 in-depth reviews of a wide range of books and DVDs written by our reviewers from many backgrounds and perspectives. We update our front page weekly and add more than thirty new reviews each month. Our editor is Christian Perring, PhD. To contact him, use one of the forms available here.

Can't remember our URL? Access our reviews directly via 'metapsychology.net'


Metapsychology Online reviewers normally receive gratis review copies of the items they review.
Metapsychology Online receives a commission from Amazon.com for purchases through this site, which helps us send review copies to reviewers. Please support us by making your Amazon.com purchases through our Amazon links. We thank you for your support!


Join our e-mail list!: Metapsychology New Review Announcements: Sent out monthly, these announcements list our recent reviews. To subscribe, click here.

Interested in becoming a book reviewer for Metapsychology? Currently, we especially need thoughtful reviewers for books in fiction, self-help and popular psychology. To apply, write to our editor.

Metapsychology Online Reviews

Promote your Page too

Metapsychology Online Reviews
ISSN 1931-5716