email page print pageAll Topic Reviews
10 Minute Solution: High Intensity Interval Training12 and Holding3-In-1 Total Body Fitness with Desi Bartlett30 Minute Ab & Butt Blaster4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days49 Up5 Day Fit Yoga5 Mega Miles with Toning Band56 UpA Beautiful MindA Dangerous MethodA Mother's Courage: Talking Back to AutismA Short Stay in SwitzerlandA.M. EnergyAbout SchmidtAccessible Yoga for Every Body DVDAddictionAdvanced Sexual TechniquesAgeless Mobility: Pain-Free Wellness For LongevityAileen - Life and Death of a Serial KillerAlexander the LastAM/PM YogaAmerican TeacherAthlete's Guide to YogaAutism and MeBack in Action: Yoga for a Healthy BackBalanced AssetsBeautiful DreamersBecoming OrgasmicBedroom Body: Booty Burner, Core & Pelvic Floor WorkoutBeginners Meditation & Mindful StretchingBeginners Yoga DVDBeginning YogaBellyFit ElementsBethenny's Skinnygirl WorkoutBetter Sex Through YogaBeyond HatredBilly the KidBlue Is the Warmest ColorBody By BethennyBorn to Balance - Balance BasicsBoy InterruptedBoys Don't CryBreasts - A DocumentaryBreath-Centered YogaBuying SexCalm Body Clear MindCardio for Beginners with Petra KolberCinema's Sinister PsychiatristsCinema, Philosophy, BergmanCinematic MythmakingClassical Pilates Technique DVDClimatesCoastCollege Inc.Comedy IncarnateCommuneCompulsionControlCore Fusion - Pilates PlusCore Fusion - Pure Abs & ArmsCore Fusion - Thighs & GlutesCore Fusion Body SculptCore Fusion Lean & TonedCore Fusion Power SculptCore Strength PilatesCore Strength Vinyasa Yoga Power Hour with Sadie NardiniCore YogaCreative Core AbsCriminal JusticeCriminal Justice 2DahmerDance Off the Inches: Cardio Hip Hop PartyDance the Chakras Yoga WorkoutDark Beginnings of Sherlock HolmesDarwin's Brave New WorldDeep Stretch / Yin YogaDeleuze and the Concepts of CinemaDetox YogaDirty Filthy Love DVDDoc Martin Series 2Dr. Andrew Weil's Guide to Eating WellDr. Yoga House CallEl Doctor, Joy Street & AsparagusElement: Targeted Toning Pilates for BeginnersElement: Yoga for Stress Relief & FlexibilityElements of Yoga, Earth FoundationsElements of Yoga, Fire DynamicElements of Yoga: Air & WaterEnjoying Guilty PleasuresEternal Sunshine Of The Spotless MindEternal Sunshine of the Spotless MindEthics at the CinemaEvamarie Pilipuf's Yoga Express DVDEvery Day Yoga for Every Body DVDEveryday Workout for the Everyday WomanEveryday Yoga for Stress Release Examined LifeExhale Core Fusion 30 Day SculptExileExperimenterFacing Death: Elisabeth Kubler-RossFagbugFamily YogaFilm StudiesFire on the Mountain DVDFit Family Fun CircuitFit in 5 DVDFlat Abs PilatesFlow and YinFlow YogaFluid Power Vinyasa Flow YogaFragile DVDGabriel & MeGaiam Pilates Slide and Sculpt Kit with DVDGaiam Pilates Total Toning KitGaiam Yoga For Weight Loss KitGet Ripped & ChiseledGet RIPPED! 1000 #3Get RIPPED! and Jacked - The Boomer WorkoutGirl, InterruptedGirlhoodGoddess WorshipGood FortuneHalf Broken ThingsHappy Yoga DVDHard CandyHealing Through Movement: Pilates Head to ToeHealing VoicesHealthy Sexy Beautiful Kundalini YogaHeimaHelvetica: A documentary filmHemalayaa's Yoga for Young Bodies DVDHemalayaa: Bollywood BootyHer ThirdHigh HopesHit & MissHot Body Cool Mind - Level 1Hot Body Cool Mind: Waking Energy IdentityIn My SkinIn the FamilyIn the Land of the DeafIn the Realms of the UnrealIn Treatment: Season 1Ingmar Bergman, Cinematic PhilosopherInsight Yoga Earth: Balancing Yin EnergyInsight Yoga Heaven: Balancing YangInsight Yoga with Sarah PowersIntense Games DVDInto Great SilenceIntroduction to Ashtanga Yoga DVDIntroduction to Yoga DVDIt's Kind of a Funny StoryIt's Not Me, I Swear!Janis Saffell Beverly Hills YogaJellyfishJulien Donkey-BoyJunebugKama-Sutra--The Secrets to the Art of LoveKids Teach Yoga - Flying EagleKidYogi - Yoga for ChildrenKingdom Series 2Kingdom: Series ThreeKripalu Yoga Dynamic DVDKripalu Yoga Gentle DVDKundalini Yoga : DVDKundalini Yoga for Beginners & BeyondKUNDALINI YOGA for Your Week - MONDAYKUNDALINI YOGA for Your Week - TUESDAY - CoreKundalini Yoga Meditation for Beginners & BeyondKundalini Yoga on the BallKundalini Yoga Solar Power All-In-One WorkoutKundalini Yoga to Detox and Destress DVDKundalini Yoga Transformer All-In-One WorkoutKundalini Yoga: Green Energy of the HeartLa SierraLand GirlsLand Girls Series 2Lars and the Real GirlLast Train HomeLeaving Las VegasLetting Go!Lie to Me: Season OneLife On MarsLifeForce Yoga to Beat the Blues--Level 1LifeForce Yoga to Beat the Blues: Level 2Listening to the WorldLiving Room Yoga DVDLiving Room Yoga: Twist and BendLouise BourgeoisLunacyLunar Flow YogaMad, Bad and Dangerous?MaidentripManicManufactured LandscapesMaui PilatesMayo Clinic Wellness Solutions for Back PainMayo Clinic Wellness Solutions for IBSMayo Clinic Wellness Solutions for InsomniaMementoMethadoniaMindfulness for Urban Depression: Tools for Relief from Stressful City LivingMonsterMother and SonMovies and the Moral Adventure of LifeMurderballMurderlandMurphy's LawMurphy's Law Series 2My Flesh and BloodMy Sister's KeeperMysterious CreaturesNamaste Yoga: Season 3 Part 1New American TeenagersNew Look at ADHD: Inhibition, Time, and Self-ControlNew Sex Now DVDNew Takes in Film-PhilosophyNew York PilatesNext-Level PilatesNormalNotes on a ScandalNurembergOne Flew Over the Cuckoo's NestOrgasm Inc.Pain Free at WorkPeople Like OurselvesPeople Love PhotosPerfect in Ten AbsPerfect in Ten: PilatesPerfect in Ten: StretchPerfect in Ten: YogaPhantom Museums DVDPhilosophy and the Moving ImagePhrenologyPieces of AprilPilates for BeginnersPilates for MenPink Ribbons, Inc.PollockPop & MePornographyPornographyPower to the Peaceful YogaPower YogaPower Yoga for HappinessPower Yoga: Core PowerPower Yoga: Fat BurnerPower Yoga: Strength and FlexibilityPrenatal FlowPresence Through Movement: Yin YogaPrince of PrisonersPrivate Dicks - Men ExposedPrivate Practices DVDProofProzac NationPsycho ThrillersPublic EnemiesPure and Simple YogaPure SculptPure Yoga Pilates with Kerry BestwickQi Gong Fire & Water With Matthew CohenQi Gong Flow for BeginnersQi Gong for Low Back PainQi Gong for Upper Back and Neck PainQi Gong for Weight LossQi Workout AM/PMQiGong for Healthy Joints & BonesQuick Blast MethodRachel Getting MarriedRadiant Heart Yoga DVDRain ManRated X - A Journey Through PornReach - Upbeat Toning & Flexibility for a Dancer's BodyRed Lotus YogaRelative StrangersRelax Into Yoga for SeniorsRequiem for a Dream DVDResistance Stretching With Dara TorresRestorative Yoga PracticeRestorative Yoga PracticeSara Ivanhoe's Taste DVDScreening SexSeeing Fictions in FilmSeeing the LightSergeant Cribb - The Complete SeriesSeven Challenges To Change Your Life DVDShameShort Term 12SickoSmashedSolar Flow Yoga DVDSpeakSpecial TreatmentSpectacular NowStarting Out in the EveningStep By Step Strength TrainingStep by Step Tai ChiStephen Fry in AmericaStrandedStranger Than FictionStrength & SpiritStrength, Grace, HealingStrong & SculptedStrong Body, Ageless BodySun SalutationsSunset StorySuper Seniors: Box, Balance, & Lift Surf Yoga SoulSybel's Yoga For Sports & FitnessSybel's Yoga For Sports & Fitness Vol 2SylviaSynecdoche New YorkTai Chi for Beginners with Grandmaster William C. C. ChenTarnationTeen YogaTeenYogi DVDTemple GrandinTen Zen Tummy TonersTerrence MalickThe Athlete's Guide to YogaThe Better Sex Guide to the Kama SutraThe Big Book of PornThe Booty Barre -Total New BodyThe Breath of Tantric LoveThe ClassThe Devil and Daniel JohnstonThe Devil, ProbablyThe f WordThe f WordThe f WordThe F Word - Series ThreeThe f Word -- Series FourThe FIRM Power Yoga DVDThe Horse BoyThe Matrix and PhilosophyThe Medicated ChildThe Perfect ExerciseThe Philosophy of Motion PicturesThe Power of ForgivenessThe Qi Healing KitThe ReaderThe SavagesThe Snake PitThe Stanford Prison ExperimentThe Street Complete CollectionThe Suicide TouristThe Three Faces of EveThe Ultimate BALLET YOGAThe Way Way BackThinThinking XXXThis Emotional Life: In Search of Ourselves...and HappinessThrough A Dog's EyesThrough Deaf EyesThumbsuckerTierney GearonTo the WonderToday and TomorrowTotal-Body ToningTransTransform Yourself with Jivamukti YogaTrial and RetributionTrial and Retribution: Set 1Trial and Retribution: Set 3Trudie Styler's Cardio Dance FlowTrudie Styler's Warrior YogaUnborn in the USA: Inside the War on AbortionUnderstanding LoveUnforgettableUp the YangtzeV-Core WorkoutViniyoga Therapy for AnxietyViniyoga Therapy for DepressionViniyoga Therapy for the Low Back, Sacrum and HipsViniyoga Therapy for the Upper Back, Neck and ShouldersWaking LifeWalk It Off in 30 DaysWalk to the HITS Radio RemixesWall: A World DividedWeight Loss Cardio KickWhat Remains: The Life and Work of Sally MannWhat to Do When Someone DiesWhen Did You Last See Your Father?When Worlds Collide: The Untold Story of the Americas after ColumbusWrinklesWristcutters: A Love StoryWrong Side of the BusYin Yoga DVDYogaYoga & Pilates Workouts for DummiesYoga 4 TeensYoga : Beginners Flow for EveryoneYoga Beauty BodyYoga Bliss HipsYoga Body : Lean & Defined Total Body WorkoutYoga By Teens DVDYoga Emergency DVD: Arms & ShouldersYoga Emergency DVD: BackYoga Emergency DVD: Full Leg StretchYoga Emergency DVD: HipsYoga Emergency DVD: PregnancyYoga Flow DVDYoga for Back CareYoga for BeginnersYoga for Energy & Stress ReliefYoga for FitnessYoga for Regular Guys DVDYoga for Strength & EnergyYoga for Strength & FlexibilityYoga for the Young at HeartYoga for Your WeekYoga Inside Out: Go DeeperYoga Inside Out: The Healing WayYoga Journal's Yoga for StressYoga Journal: Yoga for Strength and Toning DVDYoga Link: Core IntegrationYoga Link: Hip HelpersYoga Link: Shoulder Shape-UpYoga on DemandYoga Quick FixesYoga SculptYoga ShaktiYoga Therapy for Back PainYoga Therapy Prescriptions - 60 Health Restorative SequencesYoga To Go's Yoga Quick Fixes DVDYoga to the Rescue - Feel Good from Head to ToeYoga to the Rescue for Back PainYoga to the Rescue for Neck & ShouldersYoga Weight Loss for DummiesYoga: Freedom from Back PainYoga: Relief from Neck and Shoulder PainYoga: Spirit of Vinyasa FlowYogawoman[email protected]Your Body Breakthru - Your Best Body Circuit DVD
In Cinema, Philosophy, Bergman Paisley Livingston asks whether films make their own contribution to deal with philosophical questions (Part I of the book). He defends an intentionalist stance towards film analysis (Part II of the book), and then illustrates this approach by analyzing films by the Swedish director Ingmar Bergman (Part III of the book).
Using films as philosophical material has become an established method in the teaching of philosophy. In this way films are used to illustrate some problem or some perspective on the human condition. In this perspective films make no contribution on their own: all they show could be said in philosophical texts, but they convey the issue more lively and involve our emotional reactions. On a contrary perspective there is 'film as philosophizing'. Livingston is not unambiguous in supporting one of these theses. He denies that films confirm any philosophical thesis, thus they can only illustrate them. He challenges those who claim a genuine way of philosophizing here as facing the dilemma or either this philosophizing being inexpressible with texts (thus mysterious) or not genuine. That films have other means than texts is trivial: they use pictures, montages, combinations of music and scenery etc. Their main role seems to be probing options: 'In the absence of such empirically justified bridging assumptions, fiction-based reasoning should be viewed as a kind of hypothesis formation' (197). Seen this way films are useful -- as are other fictions -- in providing thought experiments or possible scenarios to probe our views or understanding of an issue. They serve as some 'context of discovery'. At the very end of the book Livingston claims that there are cases 'where the film-maker, or team of film-makers, has something genuinely valuable to express about a philosophical topic and has successfully done so with a film' (199), but neither criteria for 'something genuinely valuable' nor examples are given, even the Bergman films don't have to be seen as genuinely valuable. Earlier he had stressed: 'films may have a heuristic role in the context of ongoing investigations within a number of avenues of philosophical enquiry' (36).
In interpreting traditional philosophy one often distinguishes between a systematic (re-constructive) approach and an intentionalist approach. The systematic approach takes parts of the philosophical tradition and its texts as building blocks for current systematic theories. Texts are taken as having objective meaning mostly independent from their historical embedding. They are seen as (partial) contributions to state of the art theories. The intentionalist approach, on the other hand, focuses on the author's intention and the exact statement of his or her theses in light of his or her influences and other works etc. This may provide a proper understanding of the authors, but incorporates all mistakes, peculiarities and errors of their theoretical systems. In practice both approaches are -- ideally -- combined: one aims at state of the art theories using the tradition, which has to be understood properly to avoid neglecting important insights or routes of exploration. A similar distinction Livingston applies to the analysis of films. One may see them as having objective meaning or as the expression of the intentions of their main creator, which often are the script writer and the director (Bergman often doing both). Livingston prefers the intentionalist approach. Therefore he has to look at the influences of a director and his self-interpretative statements. Not all films have an individual author, but in Bergman's case the intentionalist approach can be followed. Bergman rarely commented on the interpretation of his work, but stated that he used film to communicate with people about some of life's fundamental topics. On one occasion Bergman said that he was deeply influenced by a book of the Finnish philosopher Kaila (a short remark quoted by Livingston several times to stress the connection). The book has not been translated into English, so Livingston sets out its main theses, which in itself is a service to everyone interested in Bergman. These theses, however, seem pretty shallow or general. They centre on the idea that desires are often uncontrollable and shape a person's life against his or her better knowledge or behind their back. Desires and needs conflict -- and so on. Kaila is anti-Freudian (allowing for genuine non-sexual desires, devaluing the unconscious etc.), but shares the idea of authentic vs. inauthentic desire formation (belabored also by the existentialists). Kaila's ideas, however, are so general that it is too easy to find fitting examples. Livingston claims 'some of Bergman's scenes and characterizations mesh beautifully with Kaila's central points about irrational behavior' (141). Livingston shows convincingly that scenes form Bergman films fit to Kaila's ideas, but several times he uses short passages (like in Wild Strawberries involving not the main character) where the whole movie deals with other topics (the main character explicitly reflecting on death and meaning)!
Linvingston's claims with respect to Bergman that he was not only inspired by Kaila, but 'stimulated and guided' philosophical reflection. This is spelled out as using film 'vividly to illustrate, and sometimes even inspire hypotheses about the springs of human behavior' (191), 'to challenge us to improve and apply our conceptual models of both irrationality and rationality' (192). Thus we seem to have no genuine contribution of 'film as philosophizing' but film as serving philosophy and means of teaching philosophy. The subtitle of the book 'Film as Philosophy' is not corroborated in establishing or outlining a genuine other way to do philosophy beyond what can be said in texts. That does not make the films less interesting, as the very medium of films involves more of our senses and emotions than a book: films may drive a philosophical point home forcefully; they just do not make points not available in philosophical texts.
With respect to Livingston's analysis of Bergman's films Bergman enthusiasts may take issue, too. Livingston makes a convincing case against Freudian readings of Bergman films. The desire theory by Kaila better explains some of the scenes and developments. On the other hand there are certainly existentialist topics and themes in Bergman's films, even if Bergman did not study the existentialist's books thoroughly. Death and the question of the meaning of life appear crucially in films like The Seventh Seal or Light in Winter. Even in several other movies Livingston looks at there is often a passage in which the question of meaning arises or is explicitly raised by a character (both in Wild Strawberry and in Persona). The constellation of characters in the movies (again Persona or The Silence) reminds on Sartre's famous slogan 'Hell are the others'. Bergman films in this respect capture at least existentialist topics ubiquitous in the 1950s and 1960s. As short as the Bergman statement on Kaila is, there are other statements where he explicitly expresses his existentialist attitude (life being void of meaning, man facing absurdity etc.), even quoted in the book (cf. p.184) or read as fictive philosophy in a film like Persona (also analyzed in the book). As there are passages that could be directly taken from Kaila, there are passages that could directly come out of a play or novel or essay by Sartre or Camus. Their theses are far from being as general as Kaila's; even Sartre's theory of the gaze may correspond to Bergman's explicit thesis of the centrality of a character's gaze in a film (quoted on p.149). It might be that one has to distinguish several groups of Bergman films: some more existentialist, some more psychologically approaching a constellation or character development. A seemingly most Kailaesque film is From the Life of the Marionettes. To read a movie like the Seventh Seal in Linvingston's way (as being about 'irrationality' in the knight and interpreting the witch burning scene as being concerned more with morality than the absence of God) seems to me a serious misinterpretation. What Livingston shows is that Bergman is not simply an illustrator of themes from Sartre or Camus. The ideas taken up from Kaila (that desires are beyond a characters control and shape his or her destiny) are anti-existentialist and supersede, for instance, Sartre's extreme thesis that one chooses one's desires and feelings. So Bergman films are -- in a sense -- more psychologically realistic than early existentialism. Therefore they make their own contribution beyond the existentialist's plays and novels.
Cinema, Philosophy, Bergman is a useful contribution to the debate around philosophy in film and methods of spreading philosophy. It extends the intentionalist stance in literary criticism to the analysis of film. The part on Bergman may motivate Bergman enthusiasts to take another look at their favourite Bergman films.
© 2009 Manuel Bremer
Manuel Bremer, Philosophisches Institut, Universität Düsseldorf