email page print pageAll Topic Reviews
Anger and Forgiveness"Are You There Alone?"10 Good Questions about Life and DeathA Casebook of Ethical Challenges in NeuropsychologyA Companion to BioethicsA Companion to BioethicsA Companion to GenethicsA Companion to GenethicsA Companion to Muslim EthicsA Cooperative SpeciesA Critique of the Moral Defense of VegetarianismA Delicate BalanceA Life for a LifeA Life-Centered Approach to BioethicsA Matter of SecurityA Natural History of Human MoralityA Philosophical DiseaseA Practical Guide to Clinical Ethics ConsultingA Question of TrustA Sentimentalist Theory of the MindA Short Stay in SwitzerlandA Very Bad WizardA World Without ValuesAction and ResponsibilityAction Theory, Rationality and CompulsionActs of ConscienceAddiction and ResponsibilityAddiction NeuroethicsAdvance Directives in Mental HealthAfter HarmAftermathAgainst AutonomyAgainst BioethicsAgainst HealthAgainst Moral ResponsibilityAgency and AnswerabilityAgency and ResponsibilityAgency, Freedom, and Moral ResponsibilityAging, Biotechnology, and the FutureAlbert Schweitzer's Reverence for LifeAlphavilleAltruismAmerican EugenicsAmerican PsychosisAn Anthology of Psychiatric EthicsAn Introduction to EthicsAn Introduction to Evolutionary EthicsAn Introduction to Kant's Moral Philosophy And a Time to DieAnimal LessonsAnimal RightsAnimals Like UsApplied Ethics in Mental Health CareAre Women Human?Aristotle on Practical WisdomAristotle's Ethics and Moral ResponsibilityAssisted Suicide and the Right to DieAutonomyAutonomy and the Challenges to LiberalismAutonomy, Consent and the LawBabies by DesignBackslidingBad PharmaBad SoulsBasic Desert, Reactive Attitudes and Free WillBeauty JunkiesBefore ForgivingBeing AmoralBeing YourselfBending Over BackwardsBending ScienceBernard WilliamsBetter Humans?Better Than WellBeyond ChoiceBeyond GeneticsBeyond HatredBeyond Humanity?Beyond LossBeyond LossBeyond Moral JudgmentBeyond the DSM StoryBias in Psychiatric DiagnosisBioethicsBioethicsBioethics and the BrainBioethics at the MoviesBioethics Beyond the HeadlinesBioethics Critically ReconsideredBioethics in a Liberal SocietyBioethics in the ClinicBiomedical EthicsBiomedical EthicsBiomedical EthicsBiomedical EthicsBiomedical Research and BeyondBiosBioscience EthicsBipolar ChildrenBluebirdBodies out of BoundsBodies, Commodities, and BiotechnologiesBody BazaarBoundBoundaries and Boundary Violations in PsychoanalysisBraintrustBrandedBreaking the SilenceBuffy the Vampire Slayer and PhilosophyCapital PunishmentCase Studies in Biomedical Research EthicsChallenging the Stigma of Mental IllnessCharacter and Moral Psychology Character as Moral FictionChild Well-BeingChildrenChildren's RightsChoosing ChildrenChoosing Not to ChooseClinical Dilemmas in PsychotherapyClinical EthicsCloningClose toYouCoercion as CureCoercive Treatment in PsychiatryCognition of Value in Aristotle's EthicsCognitive Disability and Its Challenge to Moral Philosophy Comfortably NumbCommonsense RebellionCommunicative Action and Rational ChoiceCompetence, Condemnation, and CommitmentComprehending CareConducting Insanity EvaluationsConfidential RelationshipsConfidentiality and Mental HealthConflict of Interest in the ProfessionsConsuming KidsContemporary Debates In Applied EthicsContemporary Debates in Moral TheoryContemporary Debates in Social PhilosophyContentious IssuesContesting PsychiatryCrazy in AmericaCreating CapabilitiesCreatures Like Us?Crime and CulpabilityCrime, Punishment, and Mental IllnessCritical Perspectives in Public HealthCritical PsychiatryCrueltyCultural Assessment in Clinical PsychiatryCutting to the CoreCyborg CitizenDamaged IdentitiesDeaf Identities in the MakingDeath Is That Man Taking NamesDebating Same-Sex MarriageDecision Making, Personhood and DementiaDecoding the Ethics CodeDefining DifferenceDefining Right and Wrong in Brain ScienceDefining the Beginning and End of LifeDelusions of GenderDementiaDemocracy in What State?Demons of the Modern WorldDescriptions and PrescriptionsDesert and VirtueDesire, Practical Reason, and the GoodDestructive Trends in Mental HealthDid My Neurons Make Me Do It?Difference and IdentityDigital HemlockDigital SoulDignityDisability BioethicsDisability, Difference, DiscriminationDisordered Personalities and CrimeDisorders of VolitionDisorientation and Moral LifeDivided Minds and Successive SelvesDoes Feminism Discriminate against Men?Does Torture Work?Double Standards in Medical Research in Developing CountriesDrugs and JusticeDworkin and His CriticsDying in the Twenty-First CenturyEarly WarningEconomics and Youth ViolenceEmbodied RhetoricsEmerging Conceptual, Ethical and Policy Issues in BionanotechnologyEmotional ReasonEmotions in the Moral LifeEmotions in the Moral LifeEmpathyEmpathy and Moral DevelopmentEmpathy and MoralityEmpirical Ethics in PsychiatryEncountering NatureEncountering the Sacred in PsychotherapyEngendering International HealthEnhancing EvolutionEnhancing Human CapacitiesEnoughEros and the GoodErotic InnocenceErotic MoralityEssays on Derek Parfit's On What MattersEssays on Free Will and Moral ResponsibilityEthical Choices in Contemporary MedicineEthical Conflicts in PsychologyEthical Dilemmas in PediatricsEthical Issues in Behavioral ResearchEthical Issues in Dementia CareEthical Issues in Forensic Mental Health ResearchEthical Issues in the New GeneticsEthical LifeEthical Reasoning for Mental Health ProfessionalsEthical TheoryEthical WillsEthically Challenged ProfessionsEthicsEthicsEthicsEthics and AnimalsEthics and ScienceEthics and the A PrioriEthics and the Discovery of the UnconsciousEthics and the Metaphysics of MedicineEthics at the CinemaEthics Case Book of the American Psychoanalytic AssociationEthics Done RightEthics ExpertiseEthics for EveryoneEthics for PsychologistsEthics for the New MillenniumEthics in CyberspaceEthics in Health CareEthics In Health Services ManagementEthics in Mental Health ResearchEthics in PracticeEthics in PsychiatryEthics in PsychologyEthics in Psychotherapy and CounselingEthics of PsychiatryEthics without OntologyEthics, Culture, and PsychiatryEthics, Sexual Orientation, and Choices about ChildrenEvaluating the Science and Ethics of Research on HumansEvilEvil GenesEvil in Modern ThoughtEvil in Modern ThoughtEvolution, Gender, and RapeEvolutionary Ethics and Contemporary BiologyEvolutionary Psychology and ViolenceEvolved MoralityExperiments in EthicsExploding the Gene MythExploiting ChildhoodFacing Human SufferingFact and ValueFaking ItFalse-Memory Creation in Children and AdultsFat ShameFatal FreedomFellow-Feeling and the Moral LifeFeminism and Its DiscontentsFeminist Ethics and Social and Political PhilosophyFeminist TheoryFinal ExamFirst Do No HarmFirst, Do No HarmFlashpointFlesh WoundsForced to CareForgivenessForgivenessForgiveness and LoveForgiveness and ReconciliationForgiveness and RetributionFoucault and the Government of DisabilityFoundational Issues in Human Brain MappingFoundations of Forensic Mental Health AssessmentFree WillFree Will And Moral ResponsibilityFree Will and Reactive AttitudesFree Will, Agency, and Meaning in LifeFree?Freedom and ValueFreedom vs. InterventionFriendshipFrom Darwin to HitlerFrom Disgust to HumanityFrom Enlightenment to ReceptivityFrom Morality to Mental HealthFrom Silence to VoiceFrontiers of JusticeGender in the MirrorGenetic PoliticsGenetic ProspectsGenetic ProspectsGenetics of Original SinGenetics of Original SinGenocide's AftermathGetting RealGluttonyGood WorkGoodness & AdviceGreedGroups in ConflictGrowing Up GirlGut FeminismHabilitation, Health, and AgencyHandbook for Health Care Ethics CommitteesHandbook of BioethicsHandbook of PsychopathyHappinessHappiness and the Good LifeHappiness Is OverratedHard FeelingsHard LuckHardwired BehaviorHarmful ThoughtsHeal & ForgiveHealing PsychiatryHealth Care Ethics for PsychologistsHeterosyncraciesHistorical and Philosophical Perspectives on Biomedical EthicsHoly WarHookedHookedHow Can I Be Trusted?How Propaganda WorksHow to Do Things with Pornography How to Make Opportunity EqualHow Universities Can Help Create a Wiser WorldHow We HopeHow We Think About DementiaHuman BondingHuman EnhancementHuman GoodnessHuman Identity and BioethicsHuman TrialsHumanism, What's That?Humanitarian ReasonHumanityHumanizing MadnessI am Not Sick I Don't Need Help!I Was WrongIdentifying Hyperactive ChildrenIf That Ever Happens to MeImproving Nature?In Defense of FloggingIn Defense of SinIn Love With LifeIn Our Own ImageIn the FamilyIn the Land of the DeafIn the Name of IdentityIn the Wake of 9/11In Two MindsInformed Consent in Medical ResearchInnovation in Medical TechnologyInside Assisted LivingInside EthicsIntelligence, Race, and GeneticsIntensive CareIs Human Nature Obsolete?Is Long-Term Therapy Unethical?Is There a Duty to Die?Is There an Ethicist in the House?Issues in Philosophical CounselingJudging Children As ChildrenJust a DogJust BabiesJust CareJustice for ChildrenJustice for HedgehogsJustice in RobesJustice, Luck, and KnowledgeJustifiable ConductKant on Moral AutonomyKant's Theory of VirtueKids of CharacterKilling McVeighLack of CharacterLack of CharacterLaw and the BrainLearning About School ViolenceLeaving YouLectures on the History of Political PhilosophyLegal and Ethical Aspects of HealthcareLegal Aspects of Mental CapacityLegal ConceptionsLegalizing ProstitutionLet Them Eat ProzacLevelling the Playing FieldLiberal Education in a Knowledge SocietyLiberal EugenicsLife After FaithLife at the BottomLife, Sex, and IdeasListening to the WhispersLiving ProfessionalismLosing Matt ShepardLostLuckyMad in AmericaMad PrideMadhouseMaking Another World PossibleMaking Babies, Making FamiliesMaking Genes, Making WavesMaking Sense of Freedom and ResponsibilityMalignantMasculinity Studies and Feminist TheoryMeaning and Moral OrderMeaning in LifeMeaning in Life and Why It MattersMeans, Ends, and PersonsMedical Enhancement and PosthumanityMedical Research for HireMedicalized MasculinitiesMedically Assisted DeathMeditations for the HumanistMelancholia and MoralismMental Health Professionals, Minorities and the PoorMental Illness, Medicine and LawMerit, Meaning, and Human BondageMetaethical SubjectivismMill's UtilitarianismMind FieldsMind WarsMind WarsModern Theories of JusticeModernity and TechnologyMoney ShotMonsterMoral Acquaintances and Moral DecisionsMoral ClarityMoral CultivationMoral Development and RealityMoral Dilemmas in Real LifeMoral DimensionsMoral EntanglementsMoral FailureMoral LiteracyMoral MachinesMoral MindsMoral OriginsMoral Panics, Sex PanicsMoral ParticularismMoral PerceptionMoral PsychologyMoral Psychology: Volume IVMoral RealismMoral RelativismMoral RepairMoral Responsibility and Alternative PossibilitiesMoral Status and Human LifeMoral StealthMoral Theory at the MoviesMoral TribesMoral Value and Human DiversityMoral, Immoral, AmoralMoralismMorality and Self-InterestMorality in a Natural WorldMorality, Moral Luck and ResponsibilityMorals, Rights and Practice in the Human ServicesMorals, Rights and Practice in the Human ServicesMore Than HumanMotive and RightnessMovies and the Moral Adventure of LifeMurder in the InnMy Body PoliticMy Brain Made Me Do ItMy Sister's KeeperMy Sister's KeeperMy WayNano-Bio-EthicsNarrative MedicineNarrative ProsthesisNatural Ethical FactsNatural-Born CybogsNaturalized BioethicsNeither Bad nor MadNeoconservatismNeonatal BioethicsNeurobiology and the Development of Human MoralityNeuroethicsNeuroethicsNeuroethicsNew Takes in Film-PhilosophyNew Waves in EthicsNew Waves in MetaethicsNietzsche on Ethics and PoliticsNo Child Left DifferentNo Impact ManNormative EthicsNormativityNothing about us, without us!Oath BetrayedOf War and LawOn ApologyOn Being AuthenticOn EvilOn Human RightsOn The Stigma Of Mental IllnessOn the TakeOn Virtue EthicsOn What MattersOn What We Owe to Each OtherOne ChildOne Nation Under TherapyOne World NowOne World NowOur Bodies, Whose Property?Our Bodies, Whose Property?Our Daily MedsOur Faithfulness to the PastOur Posthuman FutureOut of EdenOut of Its MindOut of the ShadowsOverdosed AmericaOxford Handbook of Psychiatric EthicsOxford Textbook of Philosophy of PsychiatryPassionate DeliberationPatient Autonomy and the Ethics of ResponsibilityPC, M.D.Perfecting VirtuePersonal AutonomyPersonal Autonomy in SocietyPersonal Identity and EthicsPersonhood and Health CarePersons, Humanity, and the Definition of DeathPerspectives On Health And Human RightsPharmacracyPharmageddonPhilosophy and This Actual WorldPhilosophy of BiologyPhilosophy of Technology: The Technological ConditionPhysician-Assisted DyingPicturing DisabilityPilgrim at Tinker CreekPlaying God?Playing God?Political EmotionsPornlandPowerful MedicinesPractical Autonomy and BioethicsPractical EthicsPractical Ethics for PsychologistsPractical RulesPragmatic BioethicsPragmatic BioethicsPragmatic NeuroethicsPraise and BlamePreferences and Well-BeingPrimates and PhilosophersPro-Life, Pro-ChoiceProcreation and ParenthoodProfits Before People?Progress in BioethicsProperty in the BodyProzac As a Way of LifeProzac on the CouchPsychiatric Aspects of Justification, Excuse and Mitigation in Anglo-American Criminal Law Psychiatric EthicsPsychiatry and EmpirePsychological Concepts and Biological PsychiatryPsychology and Consumer CulturePsychology and LawPsychotropic Drug Prescriber's Survival GuidePublic Health LawPublic Health Law and EthicsPublic PhilosophyPunishing the Mentally IllPunishmentPursuits of WisdomPutting Morality Back Into PoliticsPutting on VirtueQuality of Life and Human DifferenceRaceRadical HopeRadical VirtuesRape Is RapeRe-creating MedicineRe-Engineering Philosophy for Limited BeingsReason's GriefReasonably ViciousReckoning With HomelessnessReconceiving Medical EthicsRecovery from SchizophreniaRedefining RapeRedesigning HumansReducing the Stigma of Mental IllnessReflections On How We LiveReframing Disease ContextuallyRefusing CareRefuting Peter Singer's Ethical TheoryRelative JusticeRelativism and Human RightsReligion ExplainedReprogeneticsRescuing JeffreyResponsibilityResponsibility and PsychopathyResponsibility and PunishmentResponsibility and PunishmentResponsibility from the MarginsResponsible GeneticsRethinking CommodificationRethinking Informed Consent in BioethicsRethinking Mental Health and DisorderRethinking RapeReturn to ReasonRevolution in PsychologyRightsRights, Democracy, and Fulfillment in the Era of Identity PoliticsRisk and Luck in Medical EthicsRobert NozickRousseau and the Dilemmas of Modernity Rule of Law, Misrule of MenRunning on RitalinSatisficing and MaximizingSchizophrenia, Culture, and SubjectivityScience and EthicsScience in the Private InterestScience, Policy, and the Value-Free IdealScience, Seeds and CyborgsScratching the Surface of BioethicsSecular Philosophy and the Religious TemperamentSeeing the LightSelf-ConstitutionSelf-Made MadnessSelf-Trust and Reproductive AutonomySentimental RulesSex Fiends, Perverts, and PedophilesSex OffendersSexual DevianceSexual EthicsSexual PredatorsSexualized BrainsShaping Our SelvesShock TherapyShould I Medicate My Child?ShunnedSick to Death and Not Going to Take It AnymoreSickoSide EffectsSidewalk StoriesSister CitizenSkeptical FeminismSocial Inclusion of People with Mental IllnessSocial JusticeSociological Perspectives on the New GeneticsSome We Love, Some We Hate, Some We EatSovereign VirtueSpiral of EntrapmentSplit DecisionsSticks and StonesStories MatterSubjectivity and Being SomebodySuffering, Death, and IdentitySuicide ProhibitionSurgery JunkiesSurgically Shaping ChildrenTaking Morality SeriouslyTaming the Troublesome ChildTechnology and the Good Life?TestimonyText and Materials on International Human RightsThe Aims of Higher EducationThe Almost MoonThe Altruistic BrainThe American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook of Forensic PsychiatryThe Animal ManifestoThe Art of LivingThe Autonomy of MoralityThe Beloved SelfThe Best Things in LifeThe Big FixThe Bioethics ReaderThe Biology and Psychology of Moral AgencyThe Blackwell Guide to Medical EthicsThe Body SilentThe BondThe Book of LifeThe Burden of SympathyThe Cambridge Companion to Virtue EthicsThe Cambridge Companion to Virtue EthicsThe Cambridge Textbook of BioethicsThe Case against Assisted SuicideThe Case Against PerfectionThe Case Against PunishmentThe Case for PerfectionThe Case of Terri SchiavoThe Challenge of Human RightsThe Code for Global EthicsThe Colonization Of Psychic SpaceThe Commercialization of Intimate LifeThe Common ThreadThe Connected SelfThe Constitution of AgencyThe Creation of PsychopharmacologyThe Criminal BrainThe Decency WarsThe Difficult-to-Treat Psychiatric PatientThe Disability PendulumThe Disability Rights Movement: From Charity to ConfrontationThe Domain of ReasonsThe Double-Edged HelixThe Duty to ProtectThe Emotional Construction of MoralsThe End of Ethics in a Technological SocietyThe End of Stigma?The Essentials of New York Mental Health LawThe Ethical BrainThe Ethical Dimensions of the Biological and Health SciencesThe Ethics of BioethicsThe Ethics of ParenthoodThe Ethics of SightseeingThe Ethics of the FamilyThe Ethics of the LieThe Ethics of TransplantsThe Ethics ToolkitThe Evolution of Mental Health LawThe Evolution of MoralityThe FamilyThe Fat Studies ReaderThe Forgiveness ProjectThe Form of Practical KnowledgeThe Fountain of YouthThe Freedom ParadoxThe Future of Assisted Suicide and EuthanasiaThe Future of Human NatureThe Good BookThe Good LifeThe Great BetrayalThe Handbook of Disability StudiesThe Healing VirtuesThe High Price of MaterialismThe History of Human RightsThe HorizonThe Idea of JusticeThe Ideal of NatureThe Illusion of Freedom and EqualityThe Immortal Life of Henrietta LacksThe Importance of Being UnderstoodThe Insanity OffenseThe Joy of SecularismThe Language PoliceThe Last Normal ChildThe Last UtopiaThe Limits of MedicineThe LobotomistThe Love CureThe Lucifer EffectThe Manual of EpictetusThe Mark of ShameThe Meaning of NiceThe Medicalization of SocietyThe Merck DruggernautThe Mind Has MountainsThe Modern Art of DyingThe Modern SavageThe Moral ArcThe Moral BrainThe Moral Demands of MemoryThe Moral FoolThe Moral MindThe Moral Psychology HandbookThe Moral, Social, and Commercial Imperatives of Genetic Testing and ScreeningThe Most Good You Can DoThe Myth of ChoiceThe Myth of the Moral BrainThe Nature of NormativityThe New Disability HistoryThe New Genetic MedicineThe New Religious IntoleranceThe Offensive InternetThe Origins of FairnessThe Oxford Handbook of Animal EthicsThe Oxford Handbook of Ethics at the End of LifeThe Perfect BabyThe Philosophy of NeedThe Philosophy of PornographyThe Philosophy of PsychiatryThe Politics Of LustThe Portable Ethicist for Mental Health Professionals The Power of Religion in the Public SphereThe Price of PerfectionThe Price of TruthThe Problem of PunishmentThe Prosthetic ImpulseThe Psychology of Good and EvilThe Psychology of Good and EvilThe PsychopathThe Purity MythThe Pursuit of PerfectionThe Relevance of Philosophy to LifeThe Right Road to Radical FreedomThe Right to Be ParentsThe Righteous MindThe Root of All EvilThe Rules of InsanityThe Second SexismThe Second-Person StandpointThe Silent World of Doctor and PatientThe Sleep of ReasonThe Social Psychology of Good and EvilThe Social Psychology of MoralityThe Social Psychology of MoralityThe Speed of DarkThe Stem Cell ControversyThe Stem Cell ControversyThe Story of Cruel and UnusualThe Story WithinThe Stubborn System of Moral ResponsibilityThe Suicide TouristThe Terrible GiftThe Theory of OptionsThe Therapy of DesireThe Trauma of Psychological TortureThe Trauma of Psychological TortureThe Triple HelixThe Trolley Problem MysteriesThe Trouble with DiversityThe Truth About the Drug CompaniesThe Ugly LawsThe Varieties of Religious ExperienceThe Virtues of HappinessThe Virtuous Life in Greek EthicsThe Virtuous PsychiatristThe Voice of Breast Cancer in Medicine and BioethicsThe War Against BoysThe War for Children's MindsThe Whole ChildThe Woman RacketThe Worldwide Practice of TortureTherapy with ChildrenThieves of VirtueThree Generations, No ImbecilesTimes of Triumph, Times of DoubtTolerance Among The VirtuesTolerance and the Ethical LifeTolerationToxic PsychiatryTrauma, Truth and ReconciliationTreatment Kind and FairTrusting on the EdgeTry to RememberUltimate JudgementUnborn in the USA: Inside the War on AbortionUndermining ScienceUnderstanding AbortionUnderstanding CloningUnderstanding EmotionsUnderstanding EvilUnderstanding Moral ObligationUnderstanding Physician-Pharmaceutical Industry InteractionsUnderstanding TerrorismUnderstanding the GenomeUnderstanding the Stigma of Mental IllnessUnderstanding Treatment Without ConsentUnhingedUnprincipled VirtueUnsanctifying Human Life: Essays on EthicsUnspeakable Acts, Ordinary PeopleUp in FlamesUpheavals of ThoughtUsers and Abusers of PsychiatryValue-Free Science?Values and Psychiatric DiagnosisValues in ConflictVegetarianismViolence and Mental DisorderVirtue EthicsVirtue, Rules, and JusticeVirtue, Vice, and PersonalityVirtues and Their VicesWar Against the WeakWar, Torture and TerrorismWarrior's DishonourWeaknessWelfare and Rational CareWhat Genes Can't DoWhat Have We DoneWhat Is a Human?What Is Good and WhyWhat Is Good and WhyWhat Is the Good Life?What Price Better Health?What Should I Do?What We Owe to Each OtherWhat Would Aristotle Do?What's Good on TVWhat's Normal?What's Wrong with Children's RightsWhat's Wrong with Homosexuality?What's Wrong With Morality?When Is Discrimination Wrong?Who Holds the Moral High Ground?Who Owns YouWho Qualifies for Rights?Whose America?Whose View of Life?Why Animals MatterWhy Animals MatterWhy I Burned My Book and Other Essays on DisabilityWhy Not Kill Them All?Why Punish? How Much?Why Some Things Should Not Be for SaleWisdom, Intuition and EthicsWithout ConscienceWomen and Borderline Personality DisorderWomen and MadnessWondergenesWould You Kill the Fat Man?Wrestling with Behavioral GeneticsWriting About PatientsYou Must Be DreamingYour Genetic DestinyYour Inner FishYouth Offending and Youth Justice Yuck!
Oshana's Personal Autonomy in Society is a worthwhile but incomplete defense of the claim that the concept of social-relational autonomy (hereafter SR autonomy) is the concept of personal autonomy that best suits our pre-theoretical intuitions and our explicit beliefs and values regarding autonomy.
Notice right off that Oshana aims to explicate and defend a conception of personal autonomy, the sort of autonomy often thought necessary to the concept of an agent who is able to initiate action, be held accountable for her actions, and choose what action to perform. This conception of autonomy is often said to be equivalent to self-governance, self-determination, or self-direction. Oshana is not directly concerned with political autonomy, the status of an individual relative to the state that gets determined by constitutional founding, legislative enactment, or executive decree. But the effort to incorporate social conditions into our conception of personal autonomy seems to lead to obviating the distinction between personal and political autonomy, at least to me. Let me first review this valuable study before registering my doubts and what I think is an important implication of SR autonomy.
2. Arguing for SR Autonomy against the Alternatives
A common view about personal autonomy is that an agent has authority over herself, regardless of political status, customary social role, or legally authorization, merely because an agent can initiate action of her own. I shall refer to any of these statuses, relations, or roles as a 'social fact,' without using 'fact' to make any claim about the ontology of social entities, merely as a general term for the class of things under consideration. The common view often gets explicated in theories of personal autonomy that conceive of personal autonomy solely in terms of psychological authenticity. Oshana argues that psychological authenticity is necessary for personal autonomy but is alone inadequate, and that particular social conditions are necessary for an adequate conception of personal autonomy. Oshana seeks to develop a conception of autonomy in which the individual's social status, social relations, and socially determined powers are necessary for an individual to be a self-directing agent.
Oshana briskly sets aside the main contenders for explicating the concept of autonomy as psychological authenticity, the structural and historical views. These views, associated with Harry Frankfurt, Gerald Dworkin, and John Christman have been the main contenders and the arguments and objections have been with us awhile. We can set aside the distinctions within and developments of these views for purposes of this review. Oshana's central claim is that theories that psychological authenticity is sufficient for personal autonomy fail and require supplement by social-relational condition of some sort. The central claim for SR autonomy gets stated in different ways. Sometimes she says that autonomy is "constituted in large part by the social relations people find themselves in and by the absence of other social relations" (p. 50). Other times, some social fact is claimed to be an "inherent part of what it means to be self-directed," or autonomous (p. 50). Alternatively, a social fact is said to be "essential" for autonomy.
The claim that a social fact is constitutive of autonomy implies at minimum that some social fact is necessary for autonomy. The intent might also be stronger, meaning that some social fact is essential for a person to be autonomous. 'Inherent' primarily means being an essential part but sometimes means 'necessary' or 'essential.' The use of near-synonyms leaves me uncertain at times of the logical or conceptual relationship claimed for social facts in SR autonomy theory. It is clear that SR autonomy denies that the level of individual autonomy is merely increased or decreased by social facts and that social facts are mere causal factors affecting an individual's particular exercise of autonomy but not necessarily or conceptually intrinsic to autonomy. The level of autonomy claim and the causal claim are compatible with plausible psychological authenticity theories. Oshana clearly intends something conceptual or necessary rather than contingent or empirical.
Oshana argues for SR autonomy by presenting a series of cases in which persons choose particular lives that satisfy the conditions of psychological authenticity theories but arguably are instances in which the person is not autonomous. A case entitled 'The Angel in the House,' inspired by Virginia Woolf's "Professions for Women," gets to the essential point. The angel Harriet chooses a life of subservience to other's needs, wants, and life-plans because she prefers such a life. Harriet deliberates appropriately on her choices, she evaluates her motives with as much insight as she can muster, and she has no desires to live another sort of life. Harriet is not anxious, conflicted in her will, or dissatisfied with her life. Harriet's choice is not constrained by a history in which support for alternatives is absent. Harriet's choice satisfies the conditions of the two primary psychological authenticity theories: self-endorsement by the agent and a history of choice absent interference from others (pp. 58-9).
Oshana argues that Harriet is not autonomous. "[S]he fails to be autonomous--not because she wants to be subservient but because she is subservient. Her lack of autonomy is due to her personal relations with others and to the social institutions of her society" (Italics are Oshana's; p. 59). The reasons for judging Harriet not to be autonomous are social facts. In contrast, Wilma makes the same choices as Harriet, has the same features of psychological authenticity and same lack of historical distortion of origins of her choice, and lives in a society where social facts are otherwise. Wilma chooses her life from among options that would bring personal growth, economic independence, and respect from others. Wilma's dedication to others is consistent with SR autonomy but Harriet's subservience is not.
Oshana gives us other cases such as 'Taliban Woman,' 'Voluntary Slavery, 'The Monk,' and 'The Would-Be Surrendered Woman' that incorporate the contrast between agents whose choices satisfy the conditions of psychological authenticity theories but fail to satisfy the SR claim that social facts are necessary for an agent to be autonomous. The last case presents a woman of whom it is true to assert all the social facts that we might think necessary for autonomy: she is financially independent, vocationally successful, respected professionally. But absent from her life is what she most wants, "surrender to the strong direction, or at least the strong arms, of a loving man" (or loving woman, we might add) so that the Would-Be Surrendered Woman does not realize her life plan. She has what the persons in the other cases lack but "her self-conception is unrealized" (p. 64). If the Would-Be Surrendered Woman is not autonomous, then either SR autonomy is not sufficient for autonomy, or social facts do not have priority over psychological facts among the conditions of autonomy, since social facts obtain but the psychological facts do not.
The psychological authenticity theorist could argue that agents such as Would-Be Surrendered Woman lack autonomy due to the agent's unhappiness with herself and the failure to fulfill her desire to for what she most wants, and Oshana cites Diana Meyers as one holder of this view (pp. 65-66). Oshana argues, however, that it is just as implausible to deny autonomy of an agent "simply because the person cannot configure her desires to her situation just as it is implausible to claim autonomy for a person who simply configures her desires to suit an unpalatable situation" (p. 66). The Would-Be Surrendered Woman is unable to eliminate her desire for a strong pair of arms but that is not reason to claim lacks autonomy. In the other cases agents shape their desires to circumstances in which the social facts claimed to be necessary for autonomy by the SR theorist do not obtain, so they are not autonomous. Oshana here claims that some degree of psychological dissatisfaction with one's life is consistent with being autonomous. This case is the basis for Oshana's denial of one alternative to SR autonomy. If SR theory is correct, then psychological authenticity in the sense of unambivalent endorsement of one's life is not a necessary condition for autonomy (p. 69).
Oshana develops the theory of SR autonomy when she describes the conditions for autonomy that she accepts: epistemic competence, rationality, procedural independence, self-respect, control, access to a range of relevant options, and social-relational properties. She also calls the latter "substantive independence" and I have referred to these properties as social facts (pp. 76-90). Social-Relational properties necessary for autonomy are:
(a) social institutions that provide minimal social and psychological security while the agent pursues his goals;
(b) the freedom to pursue goals and interests different from those in positions of authority and influence over the agent;
(c) the individual is required to take responsibility for another's needs only when doing so is related to a particular function;
(d) financial self-sufficiency adequate for material independence; and
(e) accurate information about what the agent is able to do.
Explaining, conceptualizing, and determining empirical criteria for these conditions would provide for many future research projects if other scholars want to follow through.
Of the several objections to the SR autonomy account to which Oshana responds, I shall comment on one aspect of one objection, the objection that SR autonomy is perfectionist and thus incompatible with the inclusiveness of liberal theory. The objection trades on the understanding of autonomy as a particular good that contributes to individual well-being. Liberal theories of autonomy are widely accepted and, by denying that any agent except ones who fail to satisfy minimal competency conditions are excluded from enjoying autonomous status, assert that maximal inclusiveness if a virtue of liberal theories. SR autonomy is exclusive; it says that an agent of whom one of the social-relational properties does not obtain is not autonomous. Oshana accepts that the SR autonomy theory is perfectionist and adopts the defense of perfectionist theories of autonomy developed by Thomas Hurka and Steven Wall. In Hurka's view, autonomy is a perfection that contributes to individual well-being but it is not an overriding value as it is for some liberal theorists. In responding Oshana claims that the liberal who makes this objection has conflated personal autonomy and political autonomy, which she claims to treat separately in her account. In my view, Oshana's account also conflates personal and political autonomy, which I discuss below.
Although I find parts of this study less clear than it could be, it is well-constructed and presents a valuable alternative to psychological theories of personal autonomy. I shall discuss its broadly feminist character, the risks of conflating personal and political autonomy, and one application of SR autonomy that Oshana does not mention.
Oshana's study is what I call broadly feminist in character. It is not focused on feminist issues or methods -- autonomy is of concern to many philosophers besides feminists and her methodology is typical of analytic philosophy, consisting of conceptual analysis, consideration of cases, counter-examples, and response to objections by clarifying distinctions. However, one mark of feminist thought is that the personal is the political. If we rephrase this slogan as the personal is the social, then the feminist character of this study is apparent. Tellingly, most of Oshana's examples are cases of women. I am not objecting to Oshana's account -- merely noting that the defense of SR autonomy is one of several areas where social facts seem as relevant as psychological facts for determining whether a person merits a specific status and that there is apparently no general method of resolving the dispute which of personal or social facts is more basic in every area.
I am in sympathy with several elements in Oshana's account of SR autonomy. Individual social standing seems to be necessary to a complete account of autonomy and psychological theories of autonomy give less attention to social facts than they should. Two points are worrying. First, I think many will find it hard to accept that unambivalent endorsement of one's life and whether the circumstances of one's life satisfy one's desires is not necessary to personal autonomy. There is something intuitive about the claim that what an agent endorses unreservedly for her life is necessary for it to be autonomous that I think is not shaken by Oshana's argument. The second worry is that if social-relational properties are necessary for personal autonomy or more central to the concept of personal autonomy than the alternatives to SR theory would hold, then it seems we are well along toward conflating personal and political autonomy. Again, this is unwelcome only if there are other reasons for thinking the two are utterly distinct.
The broadly feminist character of Oshana's account pushes it in the direction of conflating the concepts of personal and political autonomy if I am correct. Other liberatory movements, including movements of interest to readers of this service, that should welcome Oshana's account. There has been a widespread movement for several decades, though it is of uncertain depth, demanding greater autonomy for persons diagnosed with severe mental disorders and cognitive disabilities. Most state mental health and mental retardation systems have responded by giving some support to systems of treatment and care, rehabilitation, and financing that partially satisfy the social-relational properties Oshana lists as necessary for SR autonomy. This is a large-scale social experiment in which persons who often, on minimal evidence, superficial consideration, and motivated by prevailing theories, were judged to lack autonomy. Many have limited capacities for reflective endorsement thought essential by psychological theories. But in many cases treatment systems, fallibly, in small ways, and with the blunt instruments typical of bureaucracies, have moved toward creating the social facts necessary for SR autonomy theories.
Despite the conceptual clutter of Oshana's book, the unclarity of some conceptual analysis, and the unanswered questions about the relative importance of social and the psychological facts, it makes the case that social facts are necessary for personal autonomy. It is worth considering the issues it raises more deeply and more broadly.
© 2008 Robert L. Muhlnickel
Robert L. Muhlnickel, MSW, has been a clinician and teacher in the University of Rcohester Department of Psychiatry and is completing his Ph.D. dissertation in Philosophy at the University of Rochester. He also works on a grant training clinicians in evidence-based family practices for people with serious and persistent mental illness, co-sponsored by the NYS Office of Mental Health and University of Rochester Medical Center.
Comment on this review