email page print pageAll Topic Reviews
12 and HoldingA Guide to Asperger SyndromeA Lethal InheritanceA Mother's Courage: Talking Back to AutismA Parent's Guide to Asperger Syndrome and High-Functioning AutismA Special EducationA Toss Of The DiceA Tribe ApartA User Guide to the GF/CF Diet for Autism, Asperger Syndrome and AD/HDA Walk in the Rain With a BrainABC of Eating DisordersADD-Friendly Ways to Organize Your LifeADHD Grown UpADHD in the Schools: Assessment and Intervention StrategiesADHD NationAdolescence and Body ImageAdolescent DepressionAggression and Antisocial Behavior in Children and AdolescentsAll Alone in the UniverseAlpha GirlsAmericaAnother PlanetAntisocial Behavior in Children and AdolescentsAsperger Syndrome and Your ChildAsperger Syndrome, Adolescence, and IdentityAsperger's and GirlsAssessment of Childhood DisordersAttention Deficit DisorderAttention-Deficit Hyperactivity DisorderAttention-Deficit/Hyperactivity DisorderAutism - The Eighth Colour of the RainbowAutism and MeAutism's False ProphetsAutistic Spectrum DisordersBad GirlBeen There, Done That? DO THIS!Before I DieBetween Two WorldsBeyond AppearanceBig Mouth & Ugly GirlBipolar ChildrenBipolar Disorder in Childhood and Early AdolescenceBipolar DisordersBipolar KidsBlackwell Handbook of Childhood Cognitive DevelopmentBody Image, Eating Disorders, and ObesityBody Image, Eating Disorders, and Obesity in YouthBoy AloneBrain-Based Therapy with Children and AdolescentsBreaking PointBreathing UnderwaterBringing Up ParentsBullying and TeasingBullying PreventionBut I Love HimCan't Eat, Won't EatCaring for a Child with AutismCatalystChild and Adolescent PsychiatryChild and Adolescent Psychological DisordersChild and Adolescent PsychopathologyChild NeuropsychologyChild Well-BeingChildren and SexualityChildren Changed by TraumaChildren with Emerald EyesChildren with Sexual Behavior ProblemsChildren, Sexuality and SexualizationChildren’s Dreaming and the Development of Consciousness City of OneCommunication Issues In Autism And Asperger SyndromeConcepts of NormalityConcise Guide to Child and Adolescent PsychiatryConquering the Beast WithinConsuming KidsContesting ChildhoodCount Us InCrackedCrossesCutCyber-Safe Kids, Cyber-Savvy TeensDamageDemystifying the Autistic ExperienceDescartes' BabyDilemmas of DesireDirtyDisconnected KidsDoing SchoolDon't Bother Me Mom--I'm Learning!Don't Pick On MeDying to Be ThinEarly Intervention Programs and PoliciesEating an ArtichokeEducating Children With AutismEight Stories UpElijah's CupEmerald City BluesEmotional and Behavioral Problems of Young ChildrenEpilepticEthical Dilemmas in PediatricsEvery Girl Tells a StoryExiting NirvanaExploiting ChildhoodEye ContactFacing BipolarFamily HistoryFast GirlsForever YoungFreaks, Geeks and Asperger SyndromeFreewillFrictionGirl CultureGirl in the MirrorGirlfightingGirlhoodGirlWiseHandbook of Evidence-Based Therapies for Children and AdolescentsHandbook of Preschool Mental HealthHealing ADDHelping Children Cope With Disasters and TerrorismHelping Hyperactive KidsHelping Parents, Youth, and Teachers Understand Medications for Behavioral and Emotional ProblemsHelping Students Overcome Depression and AnxietyHelping Teens Who CutHollow KidsHope's BoyHow Infants Know MindsHow to Keep Your Teenager Out of Trouble and What to Do If You Can'tHurry Down SunshineI Am Not Joey PigzaIdentifying Hyperactive ChildrenIf Your Adolescent Has an Eating DisorderIn the Company of CraziesIncorporating Social Goals in the ClassroomIntegrated YogaIntrusive ParentingIssues for Families, Schools and CommunitiesJake RileyJoey Pigza Loses ControlJoey Pigza Swallowed the KeyJuvenile-Onset SchizophreniaKim: Empty InsideLearning and Behavior Problems in Asperger SyndromeLearning Disorders and Disorders of the Self in Children and AdolescentsLearning Outside the Lines Let Kids Be KidsLiberation's ChildrenLife As We Know ItLisa, Bright and DarkLook Me in the EyeLoserLove and SexLove That DogMad at SchoolMaking ADD WorkMaking American BoysManicMastering Anger and AggressionMaverick MindMedicating ChildrenMind FieldsMind to MindMommy I'm Still in HereMore Than a LabelMy Flesh and BloodMyths of ChildhoodNew Hope for Children and Teens with Bipolar DisorderNew Look at ADHD: Inhibition, Time, and Self-ControlNo Child Left DifferentNo Two AlikeNon-Drug Treatments for ADHDNot Much Just Chillin'NurtureShockOdd Girl OutOdd Girl Speaks OutOne Hot SecondOne in ThirteenOphelia SpeaksOphelia's MomOur Journey Through High Functioning Autism and Asperger SyndromeOut of the WoodsOvercoming ADHDOvercoming School AnxietyParenting a Child Who Has Intense EmotionsParenting Children With ADHDParenting Your Out-Of-Control TeenagerPediatric PsychopharmacologyPediatric PsychopharmacologyPediatric PsychopharmacologyPeople with HyperactivityPhobic and Anxiety Disorders in Children and AdolescentsPINSPlease Don't Label My ChildPraising Boys WellPraising Girls WellProblem Child or Quirky Kid?Problem GirlsPsychotherapy for Children and AdolescentsPsychotherapy with Children and AdolescentsPurgeRaising a Moody ChildRaising BlazeRaising Generation RxRaising Resilient ChildrenReady or Not, Here Life ComesReclaiming Our ChildrenRedressing the EmperorReducing Adolescent RiskRemembering Our ChildhoodResilience in ChildrenRethinking ADHDReweaving the Autistic TapestryRitalin is Not the Answer Action GuideRitalin NationRunning on RitalinRunning with ScissorsRutter's Child and Adolescent PsychiatrySeeing EzraSex and the American TeenagerSex, Therapy, and KidsSexting and Young PeopleSexual Teens, Sexual MediaShort Term 12Should I Medicate My Child?SmashedSnapshots of AutismSongs Without WordsSophie Spikey Has a Very Big ProblemSpeakStaying Connected to Your TeenagerStick FigureStraight Talk about Psychiatric Medications for KidsStraight Talk about Psychological Testing for KidsStraight Talk about Your Child's Mental HealthStrange SonStudent DepressionSuicidal Behavior in Children and AdolescentsSurvival Strategies for Parenting Children with Bipolar DisorderSurviving OpheliaTaking Charge of ADHD, Revised EditionTaming the Troublesome ChildTemple GrandinThe American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook Of Child And Adolescent PsychiatryThe Anti-Romantic ChildThe Bipolar ChildThe Boy Who Loved WindowsThe Boy Who Was Raised as a DogThe Buffalo TreeThe Bully Action GuideThe Bully, the Bullied, and the BystanderThe Burn JournalsThe Color of AbsenceThe Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-TimeThe Depressed ChildThe Developing MindThe Dragons of AutismThe Einstein SyndromeThe EpidemicThe Evolution of ChildhoodThe Explosive ChildThe Eyes of van GoghThe Fasting GirlThe Field of the DogsThe Flight of a DoveThe Hidden Gifts of the Introverted ChildThe Horse BoyThe Identity TrapThe Inner World of a Suicidal YouthThe Inside Story on Teen GirlsThe Kindness of StrangersThe Last Normal ChildThe Little MonsterThe Medicated ChildThe Myth of LazinessThe New Gay TeenagerThe Nurture AssumptionThe OASIS Guide to Asperger SyndromeThe Other ParentThe Perversion of YouthThe Philosophy of AutismThe Psychoanalytic Study of the ChildThe Real Truth About Teens and SexThe Ride TogetherThe Rise and Fall of the American TeenagerThe Science of ADHDThe Sex Lives of TeenagersThe Survival Guide for Kids With LD*The Unhappy ChildThen Again, Maybe I Won'tTherapy with ChildrenThings I Have to Tell YouThings Tom LikesThrough the Glass WallThumbsuckerTotally WiredTouching Spirit BearTrauma in the Lives of ChildrenTreating ADHD and Comorbid DisordersTreatment of Childhood DisordersTwistedUnder the Wolf, Under the DogUnhappy TeenagersUnstrange MindsWastedWe've Got IssuesWeather Reports from the Autism FrontWhat about the KidsWhat in the World Are Your Kids Doing Online?What Works for Whom?What Would Joey Do?What's Happening to My Body? Book for BoysWhat's Happening to My Body? Book for GirlsWhat's Happening to Tom?When Nothing Matters AnymoreWhen Your Child Has an Eating DisorderWhose America?Why Don't Students Like SchoolWill's ChoiceWinnicott On the ChildWorried All the TimeYou Hear MeYoung Minds in Social WorldsYoung People and Mental HealthYour Child, Bully or Victim?
Ethical Issues in Pediatrics
is a wonderful addition to the body of bioethics literature. It is a well
organized presentation of some of the ethical issues that can arise in the
context of pediatric medicine. The intended audience, claim the editors,
includes primary-care providers, physicians, members of ethics committees,
medical students and residents, professional philosophers, and lay people.
This is reasonable, though some members of that last group might be turned off
by the rather formal, "academic" style. The format of the book is
one of case/commentary. Clinical accounts written by physicians are paired
with commentaries written by bioethicists. The editors add their own helpful analyses
of the ethical issues at play in each case.
The introduction offers a brief
history and description of bioethics, as well as an explanation of clinical
ethics ("a patient-centered application of biomedical ethics" (p.3)).
It also provides the means for distinguishing between general clinical ethics and
pediatric clinical ethics. I will mention just a few. In general cases, a
relationship exists between patient and physician; in pediatric cases, that
relationship includes parents or guardians. In general cases, patients
participate in the decision process regarding treatments; for the most part,
that is not so in pediatric cases. And in general cases, a patient's autonomy
is to be recognized and highly respected; in pediatric cases, physicians may
have more regard for their patients' welfare than for their autonomy.
The book is divided into four
parts, each containing three chapters (each chapter centers on one case). For
brevity's sake, I will highlight one aspect of each part. But note that by
doing so I am not suggesting that the parts I ignore are lacking in interest or
The first part, Therapeutic
Misalliances, involves situations in which the ideal relationship between
patient, physician, and guardian is not realized. The ideal relationship,
called a therapeutic alliance, is one in which all parties (or, as in many
pediatric cases, the physicians and guardians) agree on the goals of treatment
and the means by which to achieve them. The first case in this part details
the struggle between a mother and the physicians charged with caring for her
infant daughter. A misalliance was created when the mother insisted that a
spiritual advisor's prescription be followed (which called for the infant to
ingest an herbal brew and also involved applications of the same herbal brew on
the infant's chest in coordination with the full moon). In the end, the mother
and the physicians reached a compromise. The infant would not ingest the tea
but would have it applied to her chest. The doctors believed that the tea
would likely do no harm and might provide some therapy.
Richard B. Miller provides
commentary for this case, and I quite like his analysis. Miller frames his
comments with a context of cultural sensitivity. The idea is that in this age
of respect for diversity, it is good for a healthcare system to act in
accordance with a patient's cultural or religious views (although such action
should be constrained by a patient's best health-related interests). This
brings out an important aspect of pediatric clinical ethics--namely, the fact
that it is an intervention into family relationships. As such, the interests
of a patient's family members must sometimes be met.
But Miller also offers an
explanation of what it means for physicians to provide adequate care, and on
this basis he objects to the way the doctors acted in this case. Part of what
it is to provide adequate care is for physicians to inform parents of possible
connections between their habits and their child's health. Miller calls this
the "transformational approach". What the doctors in this case
should have done is to look more carefully at the new age remedies used by the
mother to see if they pose a present or future health threat to her child. This
kind of education is part of the treatment that doctors ought to provide.
The second part, Medical
Futility, deals with cases involving the maintenance or withdrawal of
life-support. The term 'futile' can be understood in this context as meaning 'medically
inadvisable'. What is to be done when doctors advise against the continuation
of life-sustaining treatment and parents/guardians request it? The second case
in this part involves a child who required long-term mechanical ventilation.
Doctors in this case--guided by professional standards, experience, and concerns
about resource utilization--advised that such treatment not be pursued. The
child's mother requested that everything possible be done to maintain her child's
life, and her wishes were honored. The doctors noted that the reasons they had
for discontinuing treatment were not forceful enough to overcome the mother's
Anita Silvers takes exception to
the decision process at work in this case. She makes the important point that
clinical ethics is often guided by casuistry (case-based reasoning) rather than
ethics (principle-based reasoning). Her assessment of the case shows that the
doctors arrived at a conclusion dissimilar to their inclinations after failing
to properly categorize the case at hand. They were thus unable to apply an ethical
principle. What they ought to have done, says Silvers, is to attend to the
particulars of the case and not to its categorization into one or another
ethical paradigm. This is valuable advice, especially in a bioethics framework
and particularly in the context of pediatrics.
The third part, Life By Any
Means, focuses on three cases in which complex, invasive, and high-risk
interventions are necessary for prolonging life. One involves heart surgery
while the other two involve organ transplantation. The latter cases raise
questions about, among other things, the allocation of organs. The second case
in this part is fascinating because it has to do with the prenatal
diagnosis of a heart condition and the inclusion of an unborn person on a
transplant candidate list.
Joel Frader does a nice job of
keeping distinct the issues of appropriate treatment and appropriate allocation
of resources. He is careful not to draw any conclusions regarding one issue on
the basis of the other. In the case at hand, there is a question about which
course of treatment was the right one to prescribe. Frader's contention is
that the scarcity of donor hearts is not enough to recommend alternative
treatment in this case, primarily because the data does not yet exist to
demonstrate the comparative effectiveness of the alternative (in this case,
surgery). Frader includes a brief discussion of the morality and policies
regarding the addition of a fetus to a transplant candidate list. This is
itself a fascinating ethical issue, deserving of its own analysis (in another
The fourth part, Institutional
Impediments to Ethical Action, focuses on the problems that can be caused
or exacerbated by health-care institutions. The organization and arrangement
of these institutions is getting more and more attention because of the effect
they can have on the quality of the medical care these institutions provide. The
second case in this part was written by Joy Penticuff, a nurse educator, and
thus provides the reader with a valuable and unique perspective. Her piece
clarifies what she calls "ethics within arm's length", a notion that
points to the close proximity in which nurses stand to their patients in order
to highlight the special relationship that exists between pediatric nurses and
patients. The case involves the decision--made by the parents of a
prematurely-born infant and a hospital ethics committee--to limit the number of
attempts nurses would make to restart a failed IV (an IV that provided the
infant with her primary sources of nourishment and hydration). Penticuff
laments the lack of nurse-input in this decision, pointing out that nurses
rarely share their valuable opinions with hospital ethics boards.
In her commentary, Mary V. Rorty
offers a nice analysis of the difference between withdrawing treatment and
limiting the number of attempts to administer treatment. By her reasoning,
there is no moral difference (at least in the case at hand). The decision in
this case to limit the number of attempts rather than to simply withdraw
treatment probably reflects a psychological reluctance, prevalent in the
medical community, to withhold hydration and nutrition from young patients. No
doubt, intuitions and emotions play a part in making decisions such as the one
made in this case. But the main point of Rorty's comments echoes a point made
by Penticuff: this case is one in which the nurses ought to have been a part of
the decision-making process. By leaving them out, the parents, physicians, and
ethics committee failed to respect the nurses as active, caring moral agents.
This insight provides a valuable prescription to all health-care institutions.
Without exception, the cases in
this book are well presented and the commentaries are thoughtful and
interesting. The editors of Ethical Issues in Pediatrics are to be
congratulated for assembling this collection of works which highlight so well some
of the key issues in pediatric clinical ethics.
© 2007 Andrew Brei
Andrew Brei is working on a
dissertation entitled "Our Right to Health and Our Duty to Nature,"
and expects to receive his Ph.D. in philosophy in 2007. In the meantime, he
teaches ethics at Purdue University.