|
 email page  print page
All Topic Reviews 50 Signs of Mental IllnessA Beautiful MindA Beautiful MindA Bright Red ScreamA Casebook of Ethical Challenges in NeuropsychologyA Corner Of The UniverseA Mood ApartA Research Agenda for DSM-VA Slant of SunA War of NervesAbnormal Psychology in ContextADD-Friendly Ways to Organize Your LifeAddiction Recovery ToolsAdvance Directives in Mental HealthAggression and Antisocial Behavior in Children and AdolescentsAl-JununAlterations of ConsciousnessAm I Okay?American ManiaAmerican Psychiatric Publishing Textbook of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical NeurosciencesAn American ObsessionAngelheadAnger, Madness, and the DaimonicAnthology of a Crazy LadyApproaching NeverlandAs Nature Made HimAsylumAttention-Deficit Hyperactivity DisorderAttention-Deficit/Hyperactivity DisorderBeing Mentally Ill: A Sociological Theory Betrayal TraumaBetrayed as BoysBetter Than ProzacBetter Than WellBeyond AppearanceBeyond ReasonBinge No MoreBiological UnhappinessBipolar DisorderBipolar DisorderBipolar Disorder DemystifiedBlack-eyed SuzieBlaming the BrainBleeding to Ease the PainBluebirdBlueprints Clinical Cases in PsychiatryBody Image, Eating Disorders, and ObesityBorderline Personality DisorderBrain Circuitry and Signaling in PsychiatryBrave New BrainBreakdown of WillBrief Adolescent Therapy Homework PlannerBrief Child Therapy Homework PlannerBrief Therapy Homework PlannerCalm EnergyCassandra's DaughterCaught in the NetChild and Adolescent Treatment for Social Work PracticeChildren Changed by TraumaChronic Fatigue Syndrome (The Facts)Clinical Handbook of Psychological DisordersClinical Manual of Women's Mental HealthCognitive Theories of Mental IllnessCommonsense RebellionComprehending SuicideConcise Guide to Child and Adolescent PsychiatryConquering Post-Traumatic Stress DisorderConscience and ConvenienceConsciousnessConsole and ClassifyContesting PsychiatryCoping With TraumaCopshockCrazy for YouCrazy in AmericaCreating HysteriaCritical PsychiatryCruel CompassionCultural Assessment in Clinical PsychiatryCulture and Mental HealthCulture and Psychiatric DiagnosisCultures of NeurastheniaDaddy's GirlsDante's CureDarwinian PsychiatryDaughter of the Queen of ShebaDaughters of MadnessDeinstitutionalization And People With Intellectual DisabilitiesDelivered from DistractionDepression In Later LifeDepression SourcebookDepression-Free for LifeDescriptions and PrescriptionsDestructive Trends in Mental HealthDevil in the DetailsDiagnosis: SchizophreniaDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders DSM-IV-TRDirty Filthy Love DVDDisorders Of DesireDisrupted LivesDissociative ChildrenDivided MindsDr. Andrew Weil's Guide to Optimum HealthDr. Weisinger's Anger Work-Out BookDSM-IV SourcebookDSM-IV-TR CasebookDSM-IV-TR in ActionDSM-IV-TR Mental DisordersE-TherapyEccentricsElectroshockEmergencies in Mental Health PracticeEmergency PsychiatryEmotional and Behavioral Problems of Young ChildrenEmotions and LifeEmpowering People with Severe Mental IllnessEssential PsychopharmacologyEssentials of Cas AssessmentEssentials of Wais-III AssessmentEthics and Values in PsychotherapyEthics in Mental Health ResearchEthics in Psychiatric ResearchEthics, Culture, and PsychiatryEverything In Its PlaceFamily Experiences With Mental IllnessFatigue as a Window to the BrainFear of IntimacyFinding Iris ChangFlorid StatesFolie a DeuxFor the Love of ItForensic Nursing and Multidisciplinary Care of the Mentally Disordered OffenderFrom Trauma to TransformationGandhi's WayGender and Its Effects on PsychopathologyGender and Mental HealthGenes, Environment, and PsychopathologyGetting Your Life BackGracefully InsaneGrieving Mental IllnessHandbook of AttachmentHandbook of DepressionHandbook of Self and IdentityHealing the SplitHerbs for the MindHidden SelvesHigh RiskHope and DespairHow Clients Make Therapy WorkHow People ChangeHow to Become a SchizophrenicHughes' Outline of Modern PsychiatryHumanizing MadnessHysterical MenHystoriesI Hate You-Don't Leave MeI Never Promised You a Rose GardenI Thought I Could FlyI'm CrazyImagining RobertImpulse Control DisordersIn Others' EyesIn Two MindsInsanityIntegrated Behavioral Health CareIntegrative MedicineIntegrative Mental Health CareIntuitionJust CheckingKarl JaspersKissing DoorknobsLaw and the BrainLaw, Liberty, and PsychiatryLegal and Ethical Aspects of HealthcareLiberatory PsychiatryLife at the BottomLife at the Texas State Lunatic Asylum, 1857-1997Life Is Not a Game of PerfectLithium for MedeaLiving Outside Mental IllnessLiving with AnxietyLiving With SchizophreniaLiving with SchizophreniaLiving Without Depression and Manic DepressionLost in the MirrorLove's ExecutionerLoving Someone With Bipolar DisorderMad in AmericaMad TravelersMad, Bad and SadMadhouseMadnessMadness at HomeMadness in Buenos AiresManaged Care ContractingMandated Reporting of Suspected Child AbuseManic Depression and CreativityMary BarnesMasters of the MindMeasuring PsychopathologyMedia MadnessMedicine As MinistryMelancholy And the Care of the SoulMemory, Brain, and BeliefMental HealthMental Health At The CrossroadsMental Health Issues in Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Communities Mental Health MattersMental Health Policy in BritainMental Health Policy in BritainMental Health Professionals, Minorities and the PoorMental IllnessMental Illness and Your TownMental Illness, Medicine and LawMental SlaveryModels of MadnessMothers Who Kill Their ChildrenMozart's Brain and the Fighter PilotMultifamily Groups in the Treatment of Severe Psychiatric DisordersMuses, Madmen, and ProphetsMyths of ChildhoodNapkin NotesNeural MisfireNew Hope For People With Bipolar DisorderNight Falls FastNo Enemies WithinNolaNormalNovember of the SoulOf Two MindsOn Being Normal and Other DisordersOn Our Own, TogetherOn The Stigma Of Mental IllnessOrigins of Human NatureOut of Its MindOut of the ShadowsOvercoming Compulsive HoardingPathologies of BeliefPathways through PainPersonal Recovery and Mental IllnessPersonality Disorder: Temperament or Trauma?Pillar of SaltPoints of ViewPoppy ShakespearePosttraumatic Stress DisorderPsychiatric Cultures ComparedPsychiatric Diagnosis and ClassificationPsychiatric Genetics and GenomicsPsychiatric Illness in WomenPsychiatrists and Traditional HealersPsychiatryPsychiatry and ReligionPsychiatry in SocietyPsychological Dimensions of the SelfPsychology and the MediaPsychopathia SexualisPsychopathologyPsychopathyPsychotic DepressionQuitting the Nairobi TrioRaising a Moody ChildRapid Cognitive TherapyRebuilding Shattered LivesReclaiming Soul in Health CareReclaiming the SoulRecollection, Testimony, and Lying in Early ChildhoodRecovery from SchizophreniaRecovery in Mental IllnessRedressing the EmperorRelational Mental HealthRemembering TraumaRepressed SpacesResearch Advances in Genetics and GenomicsRestricted AccessRethinking the DSMReviving OpheliaRewarding Specialties for Mental Health CliniciansSaints, Scholars, and Schizophrenics: Mental Illness in Rural IrelandSchizophreniaSchizophrenia RevealedSchizophrenia: A Scientific Delusion?Self-Determination Theory in the ClinicShunnedShynessSigns of SafetySilencing the VoicesSlackjawSocial Cognition and SchizophreniaSocial Inclusion of People with Mental IllnessSoul Murder RevisitedSounds from the Bell JarSpeaking Our MindsSpontaneous HealingStop PretendingStraight Talk about Psychological Testing for KidsStranger Than FictionStreet CrazyStudy Guide to the DSM-IV-TRSurviving Manic DepressionSurviving SchizophreniaSurviving SchizophreniaTaking Charge of ADHD, Revised EditionTaking the Fear Out of ChangingTalking Back to PsychiatryTarnationTeen LoveTelling Is Risky BusinessTelling SecretsThe Age of InsanityThe American Psychiatric Press Textbook of PsychiatryThe American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook Of Child And Adolescent PsychiatryThe Anger WorkbookThe Anorexic SelfThe Behavioral Medicine Treatment PlannerThe Betty Ford Center Book of AnswersThe Bipolar ChildThe Bipolar Disorder Survival GuideThe Body in PsychotherapyThe Borderline Personality Disorder Survival GuideThe Broken MirrorThe Burden of SympathyThe Cambridge Medical Ethics WorkbookThe Case for Pragmatic PsychologyThe Center Cannot HoldThe Chemical Dependence Treatment Documentation SourcebookThe Chemical Dependence Treatment PlannerThe Child and Adolescent Psychotherapy Treatment PlannerThe Clinical Child Documentation SourcebookThe Clinical Documentation SourcebookThe Complete Adult Psychotherapy Treatment PlannerThe Condition of MadnessThe Construction of Power and Authority in PsychiatryThe Couples Psychotherapy Treatment PlannerThe Criminal BrainThe Cultural Context of Health, Illness, and MedicineThe Day the Voices StoppedThe Death of PsychotherapyThe Depression WorkbookThe Difficult-to-Treat Psychiatric PatientThe Early Stages of SchizophreniaThe Employee Assistance Treatment PlannerThe Employee Assistance Treatment PlannerThe Epidemiology of SchizophreniaThe Essential Family Guide to Borderline Personality DisorderThe Essentials of New York Mental Health LawThe Ethical WayThe Evolution of Mental Health LawThe Explosive ChildThe Fall Of An IconThe Fasting GirlThe Forensic Documentation SourcebookThe Forgotten MournersThe Gift of Adult ADDThe Good EaterThe Green ParrotThe Healing Power of PetsThe Heart of AddictionThe Heroic ClientThe Insanity OffenseThe Invisible PlagueThe Last Time I Wore a DressThe Limits of Autobiography The LobotomistThe Madness of Our LivesThe Mark of ShameThe Meaning of AddictionThe Meaning of MindThe Medical AdvisorThe Mind/Mood Pill BookThe Most Solitary of AfflictionsThe Mozart EffectThe Older Adult Psychotherapy Treatment PlannerThe OutsiderThe Pastoral Counseling Treatment PlannerThe PDR Family Guide to Natural Medicines & Healing TherapiesThe Places That Scare YouThe Plural SelfThe Problem of EvilThe Psychology of Religion and CopingThe Quiet RoomThe Real World Guide to Psychotherapy PracticeThe Right to Refuse Mental Health TreatmentThe Rise of Mental Health NursingThe Savage GirlThe Self-Help SourcebookThe Talking CureThe Trick Is to Keep BreathingThe Unwell BrainThe Way of TransitionThe Wing of MadnessThe Wisdom in FeelingTheoretical Evolutions in Person-Centered/Experiential TherapyTherapy's DelusionsTheraScribe 3.0 for WindowsThis is Madness TooThoughts Without a ThinkerThrough the Looking GlassTo Have Or To Be?Toxic PsychiatryTransforming MadnessTraumaTraumatic PastsTraumatic Relationships and Serious Mental DisordersTreating Affect PhobiaTreating Chronic and Severe Mental DisordersTreating Self-InjuryTreatment and Rehabilitation of Severe Mental IllnessTreatment Plans and Interventions for Depression and Anxiety DisordersTwinsUnderstanding and Treating Violent Psychiatric PatientsUnderstanding Child MolestersUnderstanding DepressionUnderstanding ParanoiaUnderstanding the Stigma of Mental IllnessUnderstanding Treatment Without ConsentUnholy MadnessUnspeakable Truths and Happy EndingsUsers and Abusers of PsychiatryViolence and Mental DisorderVoices of MadnessVoices of RecoveryVulnerability to PsychopathologyWarning: Psychiatry Can Be Hazardous to Your Mental HealthWashing My Life AwayWhen History Is a NightmareWhen the Body SpeaksWhen Walls Become DoorwaysWitchcrazeWomen and Borderline Personality DisorderWomen and Mental IllnessWomen Who Hurt ThemselvesWomen's Mental HealthWrestling with the AngelYou Must Be DreamingYour Drug May Be Your ProblemYour Miracle Brain
|
| |
In Beyond Good and Evil
Nietzsche criticizes Plato and Socrates for holding the belief that their views
are not merely one of a number of ways of seeing the world, but rather a true
account which, for this reason, cannot be resisted. Their assumption of
objectivity obscures not only the genealogy of their ideas, but the need for a
genealogy of ideas. Foucault took up this notion with the idea of discourses,
systems of statements that 'construct the objects of which they speak'. Ideas
that are free of history, have a unique authority, and in the case of
psychiatry it may be the need for authority that drives the construction of
discourses in the Foucaldian sense. From this perspective it would seem that
philosophical rather than scientific analysis would provide the most likely
critique of psychiatry. In Schizophrenia: A Scientific Delusion? Mary
Boyle is not content to settle for this. She takes on psychiatry on its own
terms: its claim to scientific status, although she has plenty to say about the
epistemological commitments of biological psychiatry. Well aware that there are
powerful historical and philosophical arguments that should be worrying for all
the psychiatric disciplines (not to mention the State, to the extent that it
accepts the legitimacy of psychiatry for the instrumental social control
function it provides) Boyle sets about undermining the authority of psychiatry,
its philosophical assumptions, scientific status and historical origins.
This is the second edition of
Boyle's book, the first being in 1990. In the past decade the book has gained a
place as one of the standard critiques of psychiatry. As such it is often cited
by authors sketching out a map of opinion in psychiatry, including its defenders.
The book is organized into eight chapters. The first provides an analysis of
the validity of the concept of schizophrenia; the next two an historical
outline of the development of psychiatry in the West, including a critique of
the frameworks provided by Kraeplin, Bleuler and Schneider. By the end of
chapter three Boyle's position is clear. Schizophrenia is a concept the
validity of which is doubtful at best. Exploration of its scientific basis,
while it must be undertaken for the sake of completeness, seems superfluous
given that the 'science' of psychiatry must proceed from such a dubious
conceptual foundation. The next three chapters explore the development of
diagnostic criteria, the current criteria for inferring schizophrenia, and the
area of genetic research.
Chapter seven asks how such a problematic concept is
maintained, despite what in Boyle's view is overwhelming evidence against it.
In the final chapter Boyle discusses alternatives to schizophrenia,
particularly cognitive behavioral therapy.
Boyle employs a social
constructionist framework in her critique, and uses this to good effect in
showing the contingent nature of the central concepts and the very enterprise
of psychiatry. She describes the history of the asylum and the claim of the
19th century alienists to an authority to speak on madness. The parallels with
current debates are compelling, especially the promise of a biological
explanation for madness. A quote from an 1858 edition of the Journal of Mental
Science has a contemporary ring:
Insanity is purely a disease of the brain. The
physician is now the responsible guardian of the lunatic, and must ever remain
so.
A central function of social constructionist analysis is to
undermine beliefs in ideas we have come to regard as inevitable. Psychiatry is
good target in this regard. Boyle's analysis of cognitive behavioral therapy
shows that even alternatives to 'schizophrenia' are imbued with language that
implicitly accepts fundamental aspects of the dominant model. Terms such as 'illness',
symptom', and 'treatment' all suggest that CBT, while proposing a different
conceptual and treatment framework, actually recreates the medicalized view of
schizophrenia. Boyle draws on comparisons with Tukes 'moral treatment' to
provide an historical example of how a dominant group will appropriate its
alternatives, rather than directly contest its territory.
A point that is made more than once
in the book is that psychiatry by itself cannot maintain its authority and
power. It is only by being granted legitimacy by society that psychiatry is
able to command the status needed to speak on madness and its management. Thus
psychiatry does not unilaterally construct the discourses essential to its
power. However this point is somewhat underdeveloped, as the history of
madness is cast as a struggle between psychiatry and those caught in its web of
vague concepts, dubious diagnostic practices and self-fulfilling research
programs.
If Boyle provides a compelling
critique of psychiatry she is less than fulsome in considering the limits to
social constructionist analysis. Other critics employing a social
constructionist framework have allowed that there may be, if not an essence, at
least something beyond language and rhetoric, something real that psychiatry is
'about'. Horowitz, for example in Creating Mental Illness, gives a hierarchy of
concepts of mental disorder, according disease status to disorders like
schizophrenia. Boyle is uncompromising in her application of social
constructionist analysis. Schizophrenia is socially constructed; it therefore
not only has no scientific status, it is just not the sort of thing than can
earn such status. In the last chapter Boyle suggests that what we have come to
know as schizophrenia is a result of power imbalances in society. This argument
is supported by examples of delusional beliefs that on closer examination
reflect prevailing social structures; hallucinations that give voice to
perpetrators of trauma. The proper way to assist those currently diagnosed is
to help them understand the forces that shape their experience and, presumably
by virtue of this, to overcome them.
There is a polemical tone to this
book. While the critical task of undermining the authority of ideas that
underpin psychiatry is largely successful, there is no convincing account of
what is actually going on in 'schizophrenia'. Boyle seems reluctant to concede
that there is anything more than language and its employment in enacting power
relationships. Just as ideological biological psychiatrists reduce all
explanations to neurochemistry, Boyle seems unwilling to entertain anything
other than a social explanation for madness. Perhaps Boyle would reject the
idea of looking for anything 'actually going on'. Social constructionism,
after all, is anti-essentialist, and Boyle is highly critical of alternatives
that leave the individualism of psychiatry unchallenged. The prospects for a
positive theory of madness appear bleak in the face of such a denial of
essence. But this criticism should not detract from Boyle's achievement in
showing how 'schizophrenia' is a deeply problematic concept. It is
impossible to read this book and not regard schizophrenia, and the psychiatric
enterprise that is wedded to it, as a perspective on a greater something that
is not well understood. But the forces that sustain 'schizophrenia' are greater
than psychiatry. They include different sections of society, the media, popular
culture, a wide range of health professionals and caregivers, and people with
the diagnosis 'schizophrenia'.
As Boyle somewhat ruefully reflects
at, 'the tendency to remain within traditional systems of thought means that
the cautionary conclusion of the first edition still stands: it is unlikely
that alternatives to 'schizophrenia' (as distinct from its replacement with
equally problematic concepts) will develop and persist unless we
face not only the deficiencies of the concept but also the social and
intellectual habits which have allowed it to flourish' (p. 317, [original
emphasis]). While individual aspects of Boyle's work have been covered in other
publications (history of psychiatry, alternative theories of schizophrenia,
effects of drugs), Boyle has attempted to draw these diverse strands together.
The book is recommended for those wanting an extended analysis of a single
diagnostic concept, especially one that exerts a powerful hold on the
professional and public imagination.
© 2004 Tony O'Brien
Tony O'Brien, Senior Lecturer, School of Nursing,
University Auckland, New Zealand. |
